Morse Awaits Verdict in Waterboarding Case - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -

Morse Awaits Verdict in Waterboarding Case

Posted:

GEORGETOWN, Del. - The man accused of waterboarding his step-daughter is now awaiting the verdict from the jury. On Wednesday, the closing arguments were made in the case against the former Milton pediatrician Melvin Morse, facing three charges, relating to child abuse. 

After approximately three weeks of trial, the jury will make decisions on Morse's charges of assault in the 3rd degree, Endangering the Welfare of a child, and Reckless Endangering in the 1st degree. Deliberation is expected to begin Thursday morning at the Sussex County courthouse. 

Before the closing arguments began, the "Charging of the Jury" was recited by the judge, which essentially explains the instructions of deliberation. When that process was completed, Prosecutor Melanie Withers delivered her closing argument. 

She spoke emotionally about the family, telling the jury that Morse was a threat to his step-daughter. 

"The evidence in this case is that the defendant is a highly intelligent, manipulative, control freak," she said. 

Withers showed a video of the young girl, in which she told a therapist she was waterboarded. She also reminded the jury that both the girl's sister and mother, Pauline had confirmed this story on the stand just days before. 

In regards to the assault charge, she also showed a video of Morse admitting to the detective after arrest, that he had dragged the girl out of the car by the ankles on July 12, 2012. She continued to show photos of the girl's bruises on her back and legs.

The state's charges are focused on four main incidents of abuse. Other than the July dragging from the car, the state is focusing on two incidents of alleged waterboarding, and one incident of suffocation through the pinching of the girl's nose. 

The defense said that the state failed to prove the charges beyond an unreasonable doubt. Kevin Tray, one of Morse's attorneys showed another video in his closing statement, in which the young girl told a therapist she was molested by her step-sister. On the stand, the girl had admitted that this was a lie. 

As soon as the clip ended, Tray turned to the jury and said the words "complete fabrication."

Tray explained to the jury that the girl said she made this lie to try and get her step-sister out of the house. Now, he said the girl is doing the same thing, trying to get Morse out of the home. 

"She had the same motive then," he said. "And she has the same motive now."

The jury will begin deliberation on Thursday, so long as the court remains open. 

  • Delmarvawide NewsDelmarvawide NewsMore>>

  • "Not My President Day" Rally in Ocean City

    "Not My President Day" Rally in Ocean City

    Feb 17, 2018 3:49 PM2018-02-17 20:49:00 GMT
    Saturday, February 17 2018 3:49 PM EST2018-02-17 20:49:57 GMT
    A local organization in Worcester County, took their voices to the streets as they rallied against President Trump.More
    A local organization in Worcester County, took their voices to the streets as they rallied against President Trump. More
  • Traffic Stop Leads to Police Pursuit; Weapons and Drugs Seized

    Traffic Stop Leads to Police Pursuit; Weapons and Drugs Seized

    Feb 17, 2018 3:27 PM2018-02-17 20:27:00 GMT
    Saturday, February 17 2018 3:32 PM EST2018-02-17 20:32:23 GMT
    Courtesy of the Georgetown Police Department Courtesy of the Georgetown Police Department
    The Georgetown Police Department said they arrested a Brooklyn, NY, man early Friday morning after he lead them on a pursuit and had various drugs and guns in his car.More
    The Georgetown Police Department said they arrested a Brooklyn, NY, man early Friday morning after he lead them on a pursuit and had various drugs and guns in his car. More
  • Bethany Beach Bans Canopies

    Bethany Beach Bans Canopies

    Feb 16, 2018 10:40 PM2018-02-17 03:40:00 GMT
    Friday, February 16 2018 10:40 PM EST2018-02-17 03:40:15 GMT
    BETHANY BEACH, Del.- Bethany Beach is the latest Delaware beach town to ban canopies. After the required second reading of the ordinance, the town council voted 6-1 on Friday to prohibit canopies, tents, tarps and similar shading devices on their beaches More
    BETHANY BEACH, Del.- Bethany Beach is the latest Delaware beach town to ban canopies. After the required second reading of the ordinance, the town council voted 6-1 on Friday to prohibit canopies, tents, tarps and similar shading devices on their beaches More
  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Teen Arrested for Threat Against High School

    Teen Arrested for Threat Against High School

    Feb 16, 2018 3:36 PM2018-02-16 20:36:00 GMT
    Friday, February 16 2018 4:07 PM EST2018-02-16 21:07:54 GMT
    Channing Fisher; Photo Credit: DPSDChanning Fisher; Photo Credit: DPSD
    Delaware State Police have arrested a Dover teenager after it was discovered that he made a threatening comment towards a high schoolMore
    Delaware State Police have arrested a Dover teenager after it was discovered that he made a threatening comment towards a high schoolMore
  • Bethany Beach Bans Canopies

    Bethany Beach Bans Canopies

    Feb 16, 2018 10:40 PM2018-02-17 03:40:00 GMT
    Friday, February 16 2018 10:40 PM EST2018-02-17 03:40:15 GMT
    BETHANY BEACH, Del.- Bethany Beach is the latest Delaware beach town to ban canopies. After the required second reading of the ordinance, the town council voted 6-1 on Friday to prohibit canopies, tents, tarps and similar shading devices on their beaches More
    BETHANY BEACH, Del.- Bethany Beach is the latest Delaware beach town to ban canopies. After the required second reading of the ordinance, the town council voted 6-1 on Friday to prohibit canopies, tents, tarps and similar shading devices on their beaches More
  • Traffic Stop Leads to Drug Charges

    Traffic Stop Leads to Drug Charges

    Feb 16, 2018 11:42 AM2018-02-16 16:42:00 GMT
    Friday, February 16 2018 11:42 AM EST2018-02-16 16:42:42 GMT
    Carolyn Faust & George Edwards; Photo Credit: DSPDCarolyn Faust & George Edwards; Photo Credit: DSPD
    Delaware State Police arrested two suspects after a traffic stop led to the discovery of drugs in the Cool Spring Farms development on Thursday night.More
    Delaware State Police arrested two suspects after a traffic stop led to the discovery of drugs in the Cool Spring Farms development on Thursday night.More
Powered by Frankly

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 WBOC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices