Could Bundick Get 62 Separate Trials? - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -

Could Bundick Get 62 Separate Trials?

Posted:
ACCOMACK COUNTY, Va. - The judge in the case of Tonya Bundick said he wants to begin his review of a motion filed for over five dozen different trials by Monday.  The defense for convicted arsonist, Tonya Bundick, wants to have separate trials for each one of Bundick's counts of arson.

Both the defense and prosecution made their cases for and against the 62 separate trials Thursday in court.  The prosecution believes because all of the crimes had a "common plan," they should be tried together.  Commonwealth Attorney, Gary Agar, said that common plan was to enhance the relationship between Bundick, and her fiance, Charles Smith.  Smith has already plead guilty to 67 counts of arson for a crime spree that lasted from November 2012 to April 2013.  Smith told police about each of their involvements with the arson fires on the night he and Bundick were arrested.

"After she did that first one, it just seemed like some of her problems went away.  I'd basically do anything for her," Smith told police last April.

During his confession, Smith told police he believed setting fires was a stress reliever for Bundick and that he would eventually take over the operation after a night where she was nearly spotted by police.

And to Agar's argument in court Thursday, Smith told police during his confession about a problem with intimacy and why he agreed to set to many fires in Accomack County.

"Up until a few night ago, we hadn't had sex in almost 18 months and that was the only problem in our relationship.  So basically, I was doing whatever I could to keep her."

Agar said Smith and Bundick's common plan was sticking together by committing these crimes and thus all 62 of Bundick's charges should be tried together.  Bundick's attorney, Allan Zaleski, disagrees.

"I don't think that's a legal reason. But, who knows. That's Mr. Agar. He's very thoughtful," said Zaleksi after court on Thursday.

Zaleski argued that the fires Bundick allegedly played a part in all happened on different nights, at different buildings, and in different parts of the county.  They are all different crimes, and should be tried separately, according to Zaleski.  But the common plan argument used by Agar is something the judge called intriguing.  The judge said he will need time to review the testimony of both Smith and Bundick from Bundick's previous trial in Virginia Beach.  The judge also wants to review Smith's statements to police the night Bundick and Smith were arrested in Melfa, back on April 2nd of 2013.  Zaleski said that he needs to defend Bundick and believes trying her charges all together will not have their preferred ending.

Zaleski also told the media outside of court Monday that the judge's ruling is the only thing he and his client are focusing on at this time.  The decision on whether Bundick's case goes before a jury hinges on the judge's decision on this motion for separate trials.

There is no time frame, yet, as to when the judge will make a decision on that motion.

  • Delmarvawide NewsDelmarvawide NewsMore>>

  • Two Injured in Millsboro Crash

    Two Injured in Millsboro Crash

    Jul 18, 2018 7:57 AM2018-07-18 11:57:00 GMT
    Wednesday, July 18 2018 7:57 AM EDT2018-07-18 11:57:00 GMT
    Delaware State Police say two people were injured, one critically, after a pickup truck collided with an SUV Tuesday morning in Millsboro.More
    Delaware State Police say two people were injured, one critically, after a pickup truck collided with an SUV Tuesday morning in Millsboro.More
  • Tawes Crab and Clam Bake Set for Crisfield

    Tawes Crab and Clam Bake Set for Crisfield

    Jul 18, 2018 5:56 AM2018-07-18 09:56:00 GMT
    Wednesday, July 18 2018 7:41 AM EDT2018-07-18 11:41:26 GMT
    Attendees At The 40th Annual J. Millard Tawes Crab & Clam Bake  (WBOC)Attendees At The 40th Annual J. Millard Tawes Crab & Clam Bake (WBOC)
    Attendees At The 40th Annual J. Millard Tawes Crab & Clam Bake  (WBOC)Attendees At The 40th Annual J. Millard Tawes Crab & Clam Bake (WBOC)
    It's time for one of the hottest traditional events on Maryland's political calendar, especially in an election year.More
    It's time for one of the hottest traditional events on Maryland's political calendar, especially in an election year.More
  • Sidewalk Restoration Concerns Locals in Chincoteague

    Sidewalk Project Concerns Locals in Chincoteague

    Jul 17, 2018 7:29 PM2018-07-17 23:29:00 GMT
    Wednesday, July 18 2018 7:39 AM EDT2018-07-18 11:39:59 GMT
    Main Street in Chincoteague. (Photo: WBOC)Main Street in Chincoteague. (Photo: WBOC)
    Main Street in Chincoteague. (Photo: WBOC)Main Street in Chincoteague. (Photo: WBOC)
    With the Chincoteague Pony Swim only days away, the town's busiest time of the summer, many locals say a new construction project is inconvenient.More
    With the Chincoteague Pony Swim only days away, the town's busiest time of the summer, many locals say a new construction project is inconvenient. More
  • Most Popular VideosMost Popular VideosMore>>

  • Delmar Native Serves at MLB All Star Game As Nationals' Grounds Keeper

    Delmar Native Serves at MLB All Star Game As Nationals' Grounds Keeper

    WBOC Sports Director Matt Pencek was in Washington, DC at Nationals Park for the MLB All-Star Game. He profiles Jeff Fleetwood from Delmar who finds himself at Nationals Park and on the field but not as a player.

    More

    WBOC Sports Director Matt Pencek was in Washington, DC at Nationals Park for the MLB All-Star Game. He profiles Jeff Fleetwood from Delmar who finds himself at Nationals Park and on the field but not as a player.

    More
  • Police Still Searching for Suspect in Viral Video of Neighborhood Brawl

    Police Still Searching for Suspect in Viral Video of Neighborhood Brawl

    The video involves hundreds of people and a car one man used as a weapon, according to Cambridge Police. In the video, there are screams of terror as one man, police identified as 24 year-old Craig Wallace, drives the car into a group of people, knocking some down to the ground. Later in the video, the car rams into another car, barely missing one person. Police say Wallace's brother broke his leg in the incident in what appears to be a family conflict.

    More

    The video involves hundreds of people and a car one man used as a weapon, according to Cambridge Police. In the video, there are screams of terror as one man, police identified as 24 year-old Craig Wallace, drives the car into a group of people, knocking some down to the ground. Later in the video, the car rams into another car, barely missing one person. Police say Wallace's brother broke his leg in the incident in what appears to be a family conflict.

    More
  • Wicomico County Mourns the Loss of Chief David Barry

    Wicomico County Mourns the Loss of Chief David Barry

    Friends and coworkers spoke today on behalf of Fire Chief David Barry's sudden passing. The longtime volunteer firefighter was killed Saturday in a car accident in Delaware. WBOC's Erin Tyszko spent the day at the Allen Volunteer Fire Company, where Barry spent a lot of his time.

    More

    Friends and coworkers spoke today on behalf of Fire Chief David Barry's sudden passing. The longtime volunteer firefighter was killed Saturday in a car accident in Delaware. WBOC's Erin Tyszko spent the day at the Allen Volunteer Fire Company, where Barry spent a lot of his time.

    More
Powered by Frankly

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 WBOC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices