Connecticut court affirms pre-gay marriage rights - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -

Connecticut court affirms pre-gay marriage rights

Posted: Updated:
(AP Photo/Douglas Healey). FILE - This July 18, 2006 file photo shows Margaret Mueller, right, and Charlotte Stacey at their home in Norwalk, Conn. (AP Photo/Douglas Healey). FILE - This July 18, 2006 file photo shows Margaret Mueller, right, and Charlotte Stacey at their home in Norwalk, Conn.
(AP Photo/Douglas Healey). FILE - This July 18, 2006 file photo shows Margaret Mueller, right, and Charlotte Stacey at their home in Norwalk, Conn. (AP Photo/Douglas Healey). FILE - This July 18, 2006 file photo shows Margaret Mueller, right, and Charlotte Stacey at their home in Norwalk, Conn.
  • NationalMore>>

  • Century-old pipe break points to national problem

    Century-old pipe break points to national problem

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 5:37 PM EDT2014-07-30 21:37:53 GMT
    The quiet summer campus of UCLA found itself suddenly steeped in water and chaos after a major water pipe burst and spewed some eight million gallons, stranding people in parking garages and flooding the...More
    The rupture of a nearly century-old water main that ripped a 15-foot hole through Sunset Boulevard and turned a swath of the University of California, Los Angeles into a mucky swamp points to the risks and expense many...More
  • Suspect in Las Vegas crime spree describes mayhem

    Suspect in Las Vegas crime spree describes mayhem

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 5:28 PM EDT2014-07-30 21:28:50 GMT
    Police say a suspect arrested in a deadly Las Vegas home invasion told them she fought off a woman with a screwdriver to help her partner in crime as he struggled with and fatally shot the woman's husband.More
    A woman accused in a Las Vegas crime spree described to police how she stabbed a woman with a screwdriver during a violent string of mayhem that ended in the death of her partner and a homeowner.More
  • 6 Philadelphia officers charged in corruption case

    6 Philadelphia officers charged in corruption case

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 5:19 PM EDT2014-07-30 21:19:43 GMT
    Six city narcotics officers used gangland tactics to shake down drug dealers, robbing them of large sums of cash and drugs for years, federal authorities charged in an indictment unsealed Wednesday.More
    Six city narcotics officers used gangland tactics to shake down drug dealers, relying on guns, badges, beatings and threats to extort huge piles of cash and cocaine, federal authorities charged in an indictment Wednesday.More
By DAVE COLLINS
Associated Press

HARTFORD, Conn. (AP) - Connecticut's highest court ruled Wednesday that some legal rights of same-sex couples predate the state's approvals of civil unions in 2005 and gay marriage in 2008, a decision that gay rights supporters call the first of its kind in the country.

The state Supreme Court issued a 6-0 decision overturning two lower court rulings and allowing a widow to sue a doctor in a medical malpractice case for the death of her spouse and the loss of her spouse's companionship and income. The alleged malpractice occurred from 2001 to 2004, a time when only married couples were allowed to sue for loss of spousal "consortium."

"It's another example of the Connecticut Supreme Court leading the way in recognizing that the love and commitment of same-sex couples is exactly the same as different-sex couples," said Ben Klein, a lawyer for Gay & Lesbian Advocates & Defenders in Boston. "This will be an influential and important decision that other courts will look to."

Connecticut was the second state after Massachusetts to approve gay marriage. Same-sex marriage is now legal in 19 states and the District of Columbia. Gay marriage bans that have been overturned in some other states continue to make their way through the courts.

The Connecticut case involved Margaret Mueller and Charlotte Stacey, insurance industry workers who lived in Stamford and Norwalk. They had a civil union in Connecticut in 2005 and got married in Massachusetts in 2008 after 23 years together under that state's gay marriage law, shortly before the Connecticut Supreme Court approved gay marriage.

Mueller was diagnosed with ovarian cancer in 2001. In 2005, however, Mueller and Stacey learned the diagnosis was wrong and she actually had appendix cancer. Mueller died in 2009 at age 62. Stacey said her death could have been prevented if the original diagnosis had been correct.

Mueller sued for malpractice, and a jury issued a $2.4 million verdict in her favor against one doctor, Iris Wertheim, after her death, said Stacey's lawyer, Sean McElligott. Another doctor named in the lawsuit, Isidore Tepler, settled the malpractice claims.

The trial court and the state Appellate Court ruled against Stacey in her effort to sue Wertheim for loss of consortium, saying Stacey and Mueller weren't married as required under the law.

"The Supreme Court sought fit to rectify this injustice," said Stacey, 63, who now lives in Middletown. "It validates my loss of my spouse for the fact that what I suffered for the seven years that Marge had cancer ... and all that I gave up and all that I don't have because she died because of the malpractice."

The Supreme Court said it wasn't legally possible for Stacey and Mueller to be married or in a civil union at the time of the misdiagnosis, and the justices accepted the couple's contention that they would have been married long ago if allowed.

"Society has come to accept the view that committed same sex couples ... are entitled to the same social and legal recognition as committed opposite sex couples," Chief Justice Chase T. Rogers wrote in the ruling.

Lawyers in the case agreed the court ruled on an important issue but said the decision likely won't affect many other cases because gay marriage has been legal in the state for six years and the statute of limitations on civil claims is two years.

Massachusetts is the only other state where such a case was debated. That state's highest court ruled in 2008 against a lesbian widow seeking to sue for loss of companionship.

Wertheim's lawyer, Eric Stockman, said his case was about applying Connecticut legal precedent, not gay marriage.

"Dr. Wertheim fully supported and understood the relationship that Miss Stacey had with Miss Mueller," he said.

Copyright 2014 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

  • InternationalMore>>

  • Obama takes tougher line against Gaza casualties

    Obama takes tougher line against Gaza casualties

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 5:37 PM EDT2014-07-30 21:37:13 GMT
    The United States is condemning Israel's shelling of a U.N. school in the Gaza Strip that was sheltering displaced Palestinians.More
    The Obama administration condemned the deadly shelling of a United Nations school in Gaza Wednesday, using tough, yet carefully worded language that reflects growing White House irritation with Israel and the mounting...More
  • Bank scandal tarnishes powerful Portuguese family

    Bank scandal tarnishes powerful Portuguese family

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 5:29 PM EDT2014-07-30 21:29:57 GMT
    Portugal's Espirito Santo family business survived wars, dictatorship, revolution and family feuds for almost 150 years. Now, one of Europe's last banking dynasties is being stripped of its wealth and...More
    Portugal's Espirito Santo family business survived wars, dictatorship, revolution and family feuds for almost 150 years. Now, one of Europe's last banking dynasties is being stripped of its wealth and influence...More
  • Argentina officials stage 11th-hour talks in NYC

    Argentina officials stage 11th-hour talks in NYC

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 5:29 PM EDT2014-07-30 21:29:55 GMT
    Argentina's economy minister led a last-gasp effort Wednesday to strike a deal with U.S. creditors that would prevent the South American country from slipping into default.More
    Argentina's economy minister led a last-gasp effort Wednesday to strike a deal with U.S. creditors that would prevent the South American country from slipping into default.More
Powered by WorldNow

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Worldnow and WBOC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service