Judge Rules Case on Blind Ballot Tool to Continue - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -

Judge Rules Case on Blind Ballot Tool to Continue

Posted:

BALTIMORE (AP) - A federal judge says he has heard enough evidence that disabled residents can't take full advantage of absentee voting to press ahead with a lawsuit filed by the National Federation of the Blind against the state of Maryland.

U.S. District Judge Richard Bennett denied a request by a state attorney to rule Thursday on the lawsuit over voting rights for the disabled.

Bennett ruled that the case against the state of Maryland will go forward in an effort to determine whether the state should be required to implement an online ballot-marking system designed to protect the privacy of blind voters.

Lawyers for the National Federation for the Blind rested their case against the state Thursday.

The organization contends Maryland is violating the Americans with Disabilities Act, because it fails to safeguard the guaranteed right to privacy when voting.

The plaintiffs contend that blind voters currently can't even be sure if another person will record their vote as they wish. They say the ballot-marking system assures them their intended vote had been recorded. They also say the ballot-marking system enables blind and disabled voters to vote privately and independently, without having to make their vote known to an elections judge or family members.

Bennett noted that Maryland allows anyone to vote by absentee ballot, regardless of the reason.

"And there has been sufficient evidence that has been offered to me thus far to note that individuals with disabilities represented by the plaintiffs cannot take advantage of that absentee voting and are essentially being excluded in that fashion," Bennett said.

Bennett spoke after hearing testimony from a blind and deaf resident from Bowie, Maryland, who described the trouble she has experienced at polling places while trying to vote.

Janice Toothman cited having problems with poll workers programming a non-visual key card correctly so she could vote independently and privately. Toothman said poll workers even asked if someone could vote for her.

"To me, anything has got to be better than the current system," Toothman said.

The lawsuit is opposed by another group for the blind, the Maryland chapter of the American Council of the Blind. Attorneys for that group contend the online ballot system is not accessible and subject to fraud.

Cindy LaBon, the group's president, testified that she supports a fully accessible ballot-marking tool for blind voters, but the one considered for use in Maryland isn't good enough. LaBon testified she is concerned that if the current tool is implemented its shortcomings will be forgotten, and needed improvements won't be made.

"It must be fully accessible," LaBon said.

The case is being heard after the Maryland State Board of Elections failed to certify the tool. The vote was 3-1 in favor of certification, but a vote of 4-1 was needed to certify the new system.

Dan Friedman, an assistant attorney general representing the state, said the case centers on a law that requires the elections board to certify a new ballot system. He also said the state is not in conflict with the federal Americans with Disabilities law, because the plaintiffs would need to prove people with disabilities are being deprived of meaningful access to absentee voting. He said 99 percent of the state's polling places are accessible to them.

Testimony is scheduled to continue Aug. 26. Bennett said he expects to issue his opinion that week.

 

  • Delmarvawide NewsDelmarvawide NewsMore>>

  • MSP Trooper Injured in Crash with Intoxicated Driver

    MSP Trooper Injured in Crash with Intoxicated Driver

    Sunday, May 28 2017 7:44 AM EDT2017-05-28 11:44:03 GMT
    Sunday, May 28 2017 7:44 AM EDT2017-05-28 11:44:03 GMT

    Maryland State Police officials said a trooper was injured Saturday night when his cruiser was involved in an accident with a drunk driver. 

    More

    Maryland State Police officials said a trooper was injured Saturday night when his cruiser was involved in an accident with a drunk driver. 

    More
  • Virginia State Police Mourn the Loss of Special Agent

    Virginia State Police Mourn the Loss of Special Agent

    Saturday, May 27 2017 9:58 PM EDT2017-05-28 01:58:12 GMT
    Saturday, May 27 2017 9:58 PM EDT2017-05-28 01:58:12 GMT
    Special Agent Michael T. Walter, 45Special Agent Michael T. Walter, 45

    RICHMOND, Va. -- Virginia State Police are mourning the loss of an officer shot following a traffic stop Friday night. 

    More

    RICHMOND, Va. -- Virginia State Police are mourning the loss of an officer shot following a traffic stop Friday night. 

    More
  • Dover Leaders Say High-Crime Areas Will be Saturated With Police

    Dover Leaders Say High-Crime Areas Will be Saturated With Police

    Friday, May 26 2017 8:40 PM EDT2017-05-27 00:40:44 GMT
    Friday, May 26 2017 11:23 PM EDT2017-05-27 03:23:35 GMT

    DOVER, Del. -- After a number of shooting incidents in recent weeks, Dover's mayor and police chief on Friday announced officers will be focusing their efforts in high-crime areas in the city. Dover Mayor Robin Christiansen said the effort comes after the city has seen more than 20 shooting incidents in 2017 and at a time when the summer is fast approaching and children and teenagers will be leaving school. "We are not going to ease up on the people that are using our city to c...

    More

    DOVER, Del. -- After a number of shooting incidents in recent weeks, Dover's mayor and police chief on Friday announced officers will be focusing their efforts in high-crime areas in the city. Dover Mayor Robin Christiansen said the effort comes after the city has seen more than 20 shooting incidents in 2017 and at a time when the summer is fast approaching and children and teenagers will be leaving school. "We are not going to ease up on the people that are using our city to c...

    More
  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Virginia State Police Mourn the Loss of Special Agent

    Virginia State Police Mourn the Loss of Special Agent

    Saturday, May 27 2017 9:58 PM EDT2017-05-28 01:58:12 GMT
    Saturday, May 27 2017 9:58 PM EDT2017-05-28 01:58:12 GMT
    Special Agent Michael T. Walter, 45Special Agent Michael T. Walter, 45

    RICHMOND, Va. -- Virginia State Police are mourning the loss of an officer shot following a traffic stop Friday night. 

    More

    RICHMOND, Va. -- Virginia State Police are mourning the loss of an officer shot following a traffic stop Friday night. 

    More
  • MSP Trooper Injured in Crash with Intoxicated Driver

    MSP Trooper Injured in Crash with Intoxicated Driver

    Sunday, May 28 2017 7:44 AM EDT2017-05-28 11:44:03 GMT
    Sunday, May 28 2017 7:44 AM EDT2017-05-28 11:44:03 GMT

    Maryland State Police officials said a trooper was injured Saturday night when his cruiser was involved in an accident with a drunk driver. 

    More

    Maryland State Police officials said a trooper was injured Saturday night when his cruiser was involved in an accident with a drunk driver. 

    More
  • Dover Leaders Say High-Crime Areas Will be Saturated With Police

    Dover Leaders Say High-Crime Areas Will be Saturated With Police

    Friday, May 26 2017 8:40 PM EDT2017-05-27 00:40:44 GMT
    Friday, May 26 2017 11:23 PM EDT2017-05-27 03:23:35 GMT

    DOVER, Del. -- After a number of shooting incidents in recent weeks, Dover's mayor and police chief on Friday announced officers will be focusing their efforts in high-crime areas in the city. Dover Mayor Robin Christiansen said the effort comes after the city has seen more than 20 shooting incidents in 2017 and at a time when the summer is fast approaching and children and teenagers will be leaving school. "We are not going to ease up on the people that are using our city to c...

    More

    DOVER, Del. -- After a number of shooting incidents in recent weeks, Dover's mayor and police chief on Friday announced officers will be focusing their efforts in high-crime areas in the city. Dover Mayor Robin Christiansen said the effort comes after the city has seen more than 20 shooting incidents in 2017 and at a time when the summer is fast approaching and children and teenagers will be leaving school. "We are not going to ease up on the people that are using our city to c...

    More
Powered by Frankly

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2017 WBOC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices