Del. Drug Lab Scandal Could Get Cases Tossed - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -

Del. Drug Lab Scandal Could Get Cases Tossed

Posted:
WILMINGTON, Del. (AP) - Delaware's controlled substances lab was in serious disarray, with absent leadership, in the months leading up to its closing by state police earlier this year amid an evidence-tampering and theft scandal, the lab's new director testified Tuesday.
   
Robyn Quinn said her predecessor was "rarely at work," and left behind drugs and evidence among piles of documents and personal belongings in her office when she retired last year.
   
"To be honest, it was like a 'Hoarding' episode in there," Quinn said of the office mess left by former lab manager Caroline Honse.
   
Quinn also described poor communications, a lack of written policies and procedures, and lax security measures and evidence handling procedures - including unauthorized staffers accepting and logging in drug evidence from police, non-authorized employees having access to the lab office area, and chemists storing evidence in their personal lab lockers.
   
"What I've been through for the last six months, nothing would surprise me," Quinn said when asked about potential security problems with lockboxes used by couriers delivering drug evidence to the lab.
   
Quinn's testimony came on the first day of a hearing involving two drug crime defendants that could determine the fate of hundreds of drug prosecutions in Delaware.
   
The evidence-tampering scandal involving the lab, which was part of the Office of Chief Medical Examiner, already has led to the arrests of two state employees and dismissals or plea bargains in scores of drug cases.
   
Public defenders now are arguing that prosecutors cannot meet their burden of establishing the integrity of evidence sent to the lab, and that hundreds of pending drug prosecutions should therefore be dismissed.
   
"Nothing that passed through the OCME is reliable," public defender Beth Savitz told Judge William Carpenter Jr. on Tuesday.
   
Prosecutors contend that only cases in which evidence tampering or theft has been found should be considered tainted.
   
Following this week's hearing, Carpenter's ruling is expected to serve as a template for hundreds of pending drug cases involving evidence sent to the lab before it was shut down by state police in February.
   
According to Quinn, officials knew of problems in the lab long before the police intervention.
   
Quinn said the transition of leadership to her was made more difficult because Honse was rarely at work, but she suggested that Hal Brown, deputy director of the medical examiner's office, was well aware of the problems, if not their exact extent.
   
"I think he sort of knew what I was walking into," Quinn said.
   
Quinn also said she expressed doubts to police about the competency of a colleague who was picked by Brown and former chief medical examiner Dr. Richard Callery to oversee an internal audit in January.
   
Quinn said the staffer, management analyst Jack Lucey, improperly broke seals on evidence envelopes and did not handle DNA evidence according to proper standards.
   
"It was a lack of attention to detail," she said, adding that Lucey also appeared to have trouble taking directions from a female.
   
The internal audit was never completed because of the police investigation.
   
Callery, who was among the highest-paid employees in state government, was fired in July and is the target of a criminal investigation involving possible misuse of state resources. His firing came shortly after lawmakers abolished the office of chief medical examiner in June and replaced it with a new division of forensic science.
   
Honse could not immediately be reached for comment.

 

  • Delmarvawide NewsDelmarvawide NewsMore>>

  • Kent County Commissioners Lift Restrictions on Frederica-Area Property

    Kent County Commissioners Lift Restrictions on Frederica-Area Property

    Tuesday, December 18 2018 10:18 PM EST2018-12-19 03:18:57 GMT
    Tuesday, December 18 2018 10:18 PM EST2018-12-19 03:18:57 GMT
    Milford Neck Road (Photo: WBOC)Milford Neck Road (Photo: WBOC)
    Milford Neck Road (Photo: WBOC)Milford Neck Road (Photo: WBOC)
    FREDERICA, Del. -- Kent County commissioners on Tuesday voted to lift restrictions they placed last year on a property partially re-zoned for commercial purposes, a move sought by land owners seeking to attract businesses to more than 20 acres of land souMore
    FREDERICA, Del. -- Kent County commissioners on Tuesday voted to lift restrictions they placed last year on a property partially re-zoned for commercial purposes, a move sought by land owners seeking to attract businesses to more than 20 acres of land souMore
  • US Hospital Ship Returns After Treating Venezuelan Migrants

    US Hospital Ship Returns After Treating Venezuelan Migrants

    Tuesday, December 18 2018 9:00 PM EST2018-12-19 02:00:03 GMT
    Tuesday, December 18 2018 9:00 PM EST2018-12-19 02:00:03 GMT
    A U.S. Navy hospital ship has returned home after its crew treated thousands of people in Central and South America, including migrants who fled crisis-wracked Venezuela.More
    A U.S. Navy hospital ship has returned home after its crew treated thousands of people in Central and South America, including migrants who fled crisis-wracked Venezuela.    More
  • Eight Billboards Come Down in Salisbury

    Eight Billboards Come Down in Salisbury

    Tuesday, December 18 2018 6:36 PM EST2018-12-18 23:36:30 GMT
    Tuesday, December 18 2018 6:36 PM EST2018-12-18 23:36:30 GMT
    (Photo: CBS)(Photo: CBS)
    (Photo: CBS)(Photo: CBS)
    If you drove along Route 13 today, you probably noticed a few hard hats taking down billboard signs in Salisbury. The removal is one of the first steps toward replacing the bridge near the Wicomico River and Main Street.More
    If you drove along Route 13 today, you probably noticed a few hard hats taking down billboard signs in Salisbury. The removal is one of the first steps toward replacing the bridge near the Wicomico River and Main Street. More
  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Fundraiser Started for Family of Berlin Man Killed in Crash

    Fundraiser Started for Family of Berlin Man Killed in Crash

    Monday, December 17 2018 8:41 AM EST2018-12-17 13:41:12 GMT
    Monday, December 17 2018 9:52 AM EST2018-12-17 14:52:43 GMT
    William Joseph Hathaway with his wife Mary and daughter Molly. (Photo: Mary and Milly Jean Hathaway Facebook Fundraiser page)William Joseph Hathaway with his wife Mary and daughter Molly. (Photo: Mary and Milly Jean Hathaway Facebook Fundraiser page)
    William Joseph Hathaway with his wife Mary and daughter Molly. (Photo: Mary and Milly Jean Hathaway Facebook Fundraiser page)William Joseph Hathaway with his wife Mary and daughter Molly. (Photo: Mary and Milly Jean Hathaway Facebook Fundraiser page)
    Friends have organized a fundraiser for the wife and infant daughter of a Berlin, Maryland man and cast member of the reality show "Wicked Tuna: Outer Banks," who died following a Saturday afternoon car crash in Salisbury.More
    Friends have organized a fundraiser for the wife and infant daughter of a Berlin, Maryland man and cast member of the reality show "Wicked Tuna: Outer Banks," who died following a Saturday afternoon car crash in Salisbury.More
  • Update: Boat Strike Killed Whale that Washed Ashore in Lewes

    Update: Boat Strike Killed Whale that Washed Ashore in Lewes

    Tuesday, December 18 2018 12:40 PM EST2018-12-18 17:40:12 GMT
    Tuesday, December 18 2018 2:30 PM EST2018-12-18 19:30:27 GMT
    A boat strike killed a young, female humpback whale that washed ashore at Cape Henlopen State Park in Lewes, Delaware over the weekend.More
    A boat strike killed a young, female humpback whale that washed ashore at Cape Henlopen State Park in Lewes, Delaware over the weekend.More
  • Extras Needed for Indie Thriller to be Filmed Next Fall in OC

    Extras Needed for Indie Thriller to be Filmed Next Fall in OC

    Tuesday, December 18 2018 10:36 AM EST2018-12-18 15:36:27 GMT
    Tuesday, December 18 2018 10:55 AM EST2018-12-18 15:55:36 GMT
    (Photo credit: toavenge.com)(Photo credit: toavenge.com)
    (Photo credit: toavenge.com)(Photo credit: toavenge.com)
    Dozens of extras are needed for an indie thriller set to be filmed in Ocean City, Maryland beginning next fall.More
    Dozens of extras are needed for an indie thriller set to be filmed in Ocean City, Maryland beginning next fall. More
Powered by Frankly

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 WBOC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices