Judge Throws Out Ohio Inmates' Lethal Injection Lawsuit - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -

Judge Throws Out Ohio Inmates' Lethal Injection Lawsuit

Posted:

COLUMBUS, Ohio (AP) - A federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit filed by four death row inmates who challenged an Ohio law that shields the names of companies providing lethal injection drugs.

The inmates argued the new law violates free speech rights, contending in part that the measure restricts information that helps inform the public debate over capital punishment. Their attorneys have sought to stop provisions from taking effect in March.

But U.S. District Judge Gregory Frost ruled Tuesday that the inmates lacked standing, saying their challenge was not tied to "actual or imminent injuries."

Attorneys for the state had requested that the lawsuit be dismissed.

In a filing last month, Ohio's attorneys argued that nothing in the law infringes on prisoners' First Amendment rights or affects their ability to argue issues in court. They said the law denies inmates access to information in the state's hands, which is not the same as suppressing free speech.

Frost sided with the state in his decision. He wrote that the law does not suppress speech or the ability to oppose the death penalty.

"Rather, the statutory scheme simply cuts off Ohio and its employees as a source of specific information for both proponents and opponents of the death penalty," the judge said.

The inmates also allege the restrictions treat them differently than other groups, arguing that state lethal injection expert witnesses could have their identity shielded under the law, while defense witnesses wouldn't get the same protection. The state has disputed the unequal treatment allegation.

Frost noted that the dismissal "unquestionably handicaps" related litigation over Ohio's execution protocol.

"In order to challenge the use of a drug that will be used to execute them, inmates must explain why use of that drug presents a risk of substantial harm," he said. But he acknowledged that inmates aren't allowed to know where the drug came from, how it was manufactured or who was involved in its creation.

"A proponent of Kafkaesque absurdity might be proud of such a byzantine method for pursuing the protection of a constitutional right, even if the drafters of the United States Constitution might not," Frost wrote.

Supporters of the new law say shielding the names of companies that provide lethal injection drugs is necessary to protect drugmakers from harassment and ensure the state gets supplies of the drugs.

Ohio executions have been on hold since a troubling 26-minute execution a year ago during which a prisoner getting a first-ever two-drug combo repeatedly gasped and snorted.

The state has ditched that two-drug method and said it will use one of two different anesthetics in the future, neither of which it has on hand and both of which may be hard to find.

Attorneys for the inmates say there is no evidence whatsoever of companies being harassed.

The lawsuit was filed in December on behalf of Ohio death row prisoners Ronald Phillips, Raymond Tibbetts, Robert Van Hook and Grady Brinkley.

Cleveland attorney Timothy Sweeney, who represents Phillips, said they will appeal the decision.

"This extreme law needs to be fully evaluated by the courts prior to its implementation," Sweeney said in a written statement.

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Updated: Police Seek 4 Who Robbed Armored Truck Driver in Salisbury

    4 Sought in Armored Truck Robbery in Salisbury

    Jan 22, 2018 8:19 AM2018-01-22 13:19:00 GMT
    Monday, January 22 2018 3:55 PM EST2018-01-22 20:55:57 GMT
    Video surveillance photo of one of the suspects wanted for holding up an armored truck driver filling up an ATM at the SECU on Mt. Hermon Road in Salisbury. (Photo credit: Salisbury Police Department)Video surveillance photo of one of the suspects wanted for holding up an armored truck driver filling up an ATM at the SECU on Mt. Hermon Road in Salisbury. (Photo credit: Salisbury Police Department)
    Salisbury police have released a video surveillance photo of one of the four suspects wanted in connection with the Monday morning armed robbery of an armored truck driver outside the State Employees Credit Union in Salisbury, Maryland.More
    Salisbury police have released a video surveillance photo of one of the four suspects wanted in connection with the Monday morning armed robbery of an armored truck driver outside the State Employees Credit Union in Salisbury, Maryland.More
  • Women's March in Ocean City

    Women's March in Ocean City

    Jan 21, 2018 5:16 PM2018-01-21 22:16:00 GMT
    Sunday, January 21 2018 5:16 PM EST2018-01-21 22:16:28 GMT
    Hundreds of people gathered in Ocean City as part of the 2018 Women's March.More
    Hundreds of people gathered in Ocean City as part of the 2018 Women's March. More
  • Man Robbed of Cellphone in Dover Downs Parking Lot

    Man Robbed of Cellphone in Dover Downs Parking Lot

    Jan 22, 2018 10:08 AM2018-01-22 15:08:00 GMT
    Monday, January 22 2018 10:08 AM EST2018-01-22 15:08:37 GMT
    Dover Downs Casino in Dover (Photo: WBOC)Dover Downs Casino in Dover (Photo: WBOC)
    Dover police are looking for three suspects wanted for robbing a man of his cellphone at gunpoint in the parking lot of Dover Downs Hotel & Casino.More
    Dover police are looking for three suspects wanted for robbing a man of his cellphone at gunpoint in the parking lot of Dover Downs Hotel & Casino. More
  • Most Popular VideosMost Popular VideosMore>>

  • 4 Sought in Armored Truck Robbery in Salisbury

    4 Sought in Armored Truck Robbery in Salisbury

    Police are looking for four suspects wanted in connection with the armed robbery of an armored truck driver outside the State Employees Credit Union in the 1100 block of Mt. Hermon Road in Salisbury, Maryland.

    Salisbury police said the incident happened at around 7:15 a.m. Monday, and involved four armed black male suspects wearing dark clothing and masks. Following the robbery the suspects ran northbound across U.S. 50. There were no reported injuries.

    More

    Police are looking for four suspects wanted in connection with the armed robbery of an armored truck driver outside the State Employees Credit Union in the 1100 block of Mt. Hermon Road in Salisbury, Maryland.

    Salisbury police said the incident happened at around 7:15 a.m. Monday, and involved four armed black male suspects wearing dark clothing and masks. Following the robbery the suspects ran northbound across U.S. 50. There were no reported injuries.

    More
  • Women's March in Ocean City

    Women's March in Ocean City

    Hundreds of people gathered in Ocean City Sunday afternoon as part of the 2018 Women's March. The march was hosted by the Democratic Women's Club of Worcester County. As WBOC's Caroline Coles reports, the theme of the march was the encouragement of women to vote and run for office on the Eastern Shore.

    More

    Hundreds of people gathered in Ocean City Sunday afternoon as part of the 2018 Women's March. The march was hosted by the Democratic Women's Club of Worcester County. As WBOC's Caroline Coles reports, the theme of the march was the encouragement of women to vote and run for office on the Eastern Shore.

    More
  • Update: Two Dead After Trooper Involved Shooting in Salisbury

    Update: Two Dead After Trooper Involved Shooting in Salisbury

Powered by Frankly

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 WBOC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices