Climate change plan faces high-profile legal test - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -

Climate change plan faces high-profile legal test

Posted:

WASHINGTON (AP)- The centerpiece of the Obama administration's effort to tackle climate change is facing a high-profile legal test as a federal appeals court considers a plan that has triggered furious opposition from Republicans, industry figures and coal-reliant states.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit hears arguments Thursday in two cases challenging the Environmental Protection Agency's ambitious proposal to slash carbon pollution from the nation's coal-fired power plants that is blamed for global warming.

The lawsuits - one from a coalition of 15 states and another brought by Murray Energy Corp., the nation's largest privately held coal mining company - are part of a growing political attack from opponents who say the move is illegal and will kill jobs, cripple demand for coal and drive up electricity prices.

The rule proposed by the Environmental Protection Agency last year requires states to cut carbon emissions by 30 percent by 2030. It gives customized targets to each state, leaving it up to them to draw up plans to meet the targets.

EPA officials say the rule would protect public health, fight climate change and lower electricity costs by 8 percent by 2030.

But a backlash has been building. Last month, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., sent a letter urging the governors of all 50 states to defy the EPA by refusing to submit the compliance plans.

Opponents also are getting support from an unlikely ally, Harvard Law professor Laurence Tribe, an Obama mentor who has infuriated liberals by denouncing the EPA rule as unconstitutional. "Burning the Constitution should not become part of our national energy policy," Tribe told a House committee last month, representing Peabody Energy Corp., the world's largest private-sector coal company.

At issue before the court is whether the EPA has legal authority for its plan under the Clean Air Act. The agency and environmental advocacy groups have urged the court to throw the cases out as premature, since the agency won't issue a final rule until this summer.

David Doniger, director of the Natural Resources Defense Council's climate and clean air program, called the lawsuits a ploy "to dress up the political attacks being led by Mitch McConnell in the Senate and others in the House."

But Murray Energy and the states say the court should issue a rare "extraordinary writ" to stop the EPA from taking action beyond its power even before the rule becomes final. "The stakes are so high, and delay will waste enormous amounts of industry, state, and federal resources and result in increased coal fired power plant retirements that cannot be later remedied," the company said in court documents.

West Virginia and other states argue that the plan is illegal because coal-fired power plants already are regulated under a separate section of the Clean Air Act. They say the law prohibits "double regulation."

The legal debate focuses on dueling provisions added by the House and Senate to the Clean Air Act in 1990. Instead of trying to reach a compromise, Congress included both.

The rule's opponents want EPA to abide by the House language, which says if an industry is already regulated under one section of the law, it can't be regulated under a different part.

The EPA prefers the Senate version, arguing that the agency is only barred from regulating pollutants covered by another section. In this case, the agency says, the law allows it to regulate carbon dioxide, which is not already regulated under a different part of the law. Courts typically defer to an agency's interpretation when the law is ambiguous.

Tribe, the Harvard professor, also is getting a few minutes of time before the court Thursday to argue that the proposal also infringes on the right of states and the role of Congress in violation of the Constitution.

All three judges on the panel hearing the case were appointed by Republican presidents.

The states challenging the EPA's proposed rule are Alabama, Alaska, Arkansas, Indiana, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Nebraska, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Carolina, South Dakota, West Virginia, Wyoming and Wisconsin.

  • Delmarvawide NewsDelmarvawide NewsMore>>

  • Police: Lewes Woman Arrested After Striking Officer

    Police: Lewes Woman Arrested After Striking Officer

    Monday, October 22 2018 11:14 AM EDT2018-10-22 15:14:20 GMT
    Monday, October 22 2018 11:14 AM EDT2018-10-22 15:14:20 GMT
    Delaware State Police arrested a Lewes woman for assaulting a law enforcement officer Sunday night.More
    Delaware State Police arrested a Lewes woman for assaulting a law enforcement officer Sunday night.More
  • Sales are Brisk as Mega Millions Jackpot Hits Record $1.6 Billion

    Sales are Brisk as Mega Millions Jackpot Hits Record $1.6 billion

    Monday, October 22 2018 9:44 AM EDT2018-10-22 13:44:00 GMT
    Monday, October 22 2018 9:50 AM EDT2018-10-22 13:50:53 GMT
    The $1.6 billion estimated Mega Millions jackpot would be the largest prize in U.S. history . The second-largest jackpot was a $1.586 billion Powerball drawing on Jan. 13, 2016. (Photo: AP)The $1.6 billion estimated Mega Millions jackpot would be the largest prize in U.S. history . The second-largest jackpot was a $1.586 billion Powerball drawing on Jan. 13, 2016. (Photo: AP)
    The $1.6 billion estimated Mega Millions jackpot would be the largest prize in U.S. history . The second-largest jackpot was a $1.586 billion Powerball drawing on Jan. 13, 2016. (Photo: AP)The $1.6 billion estimated Mega Millions jackpot would be the largest prize in U.S. history . The second-largest jackpot was a $1.586 billion Powerball drawing on Jan. 13, 2016. (Photo: AP)
    The Mega Millions lottery may see a streak of jackpot rollovers end as it heads toward a record $1.6 billion drawing on Tuesday.More
    The Mega Millions lottery may see a streak of jackpot rollovers end as it heads toward a record $1.6 billion drawing on Tuesday.      More
  • Harrington Man Charged With 4th Offense DUI

    Harrington Man Charged With 4th Offense DUI

    Monday, October 22 2018 9:00 AM EDT2018-10-22 13:00:59 GMT
    Monday, October 22 2018 9:45 AM EDT2018-10-22 13:45:57 GMT
    A Harrington, Delaware man has been arrested and charged with driving under the influence for a fourth time.More
    A Harrington, Delaware man has been arrested and charged with driving under the influence for a fourth time. More
  • Most Popular VideosMost Popular VideosMore>>

  • Living Life to the Fullest with Beau Smith

    Living Life to the Fullest with Beau Smith

    The saying live every day like it is your last stands true for one young man on Delmarva. WBOC's Erin Tyszko takes us on a journey with Beau Smith.

    More

    The saying live every day like it is your last stands true for one young man on Delmarva. WBOC's Erin Tyszko takes us on a journey with Beau Smith.

    More
  • Somerset County Teacher Faces Child Abuse Charges

    Somerset County Teacher Faces Child Abuse Charges

    People in one Somerset County community are shocked after finding out one of their Elementary teachers is charged with allowing a man to sexually assault her 10 year old relative. 

    That teacher is 30 year-old Brittney Hughes of Salisbury, Md. Hughes was a first grade teacher at Carter  G. Woodson Elementary School in Crisfield. 

    More

    People in one Somerset County community are shocked after finding out one of their Elementary teachers is charged with allowing a man to sexually assault her 10 year old relative. 

    That teacher is 30 year-old Brittney Hughes of Salisbury, Md. Hughes was a first grade teacher at Carter  G. Woodson Elementary School in Crisfield. 

    More
  • WBOC Morning Weather: Sunday, Oct. 21, 2018

    WBOC Morning Weather: Sunday, Oct. 21, 2018

    Gear up for a chilly and windy day. The winds will stick around through much of today and it will get colder tonight. 

    More

    Gear up for a chilly and windy day. The winds will stick around through much of today and it will get colder tonight. 

    More
Powered by Frankly

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 WBOC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices