Supreme Court Hearing Appeal Over 89-Year Old Kidnapping - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -

Supreme Court Hearing Appeal Over 89-Year Old Kidnapping

Posted:
Rondaiges Harper Rondaiges Harper

DOVER, Del. - It was a brazen and highly-covered case. In March of 2013, five lives forever changed. There was of course the victim, Margaret Smith, then 89-years old, who was stuffed in the trunk of her own car for a grueling 48 hours, without food or drink.

Then there were the four teenagers that did the crime. Junia McDonald, 14 at the time and Jackelin Perez, 15 were the two that initially threw Smith into the trunk, and stole the car, according to court testimony. Multiple hours later two 17-year old boys - Phillip Brewer and Rondaiges Harper -- entered the car as well.

Now, more than two years later, the legal battles continue for Harper. Despite being convicted of carjacking and kidnapping in June of 2014, on Wednesday Harper's attorney John Brady brought an appeal to the Delaware Supreme Court. According to Brady, the fact that his client was not at the scene of the initial carjacking, makes him less liable.

The debate is all over the legal definition of a carjacking. The question is over whether it's on-going, continuing until the victim is released or if it's something that only lasts until the car is stolen.

"Mr Harper nor for his part Mr Brewer," Brady said in front of the three-judge panel. "Did not have the specific intent to take  the car away from Ms. Smith in the manner that the girls did several hours earlier."

As for the Kidnapping charge, Brady said that this was contingent on a separate felony charge. In this case, the felony was the carjacking, and so he said disproving the carjacking would simultaneously call for a lesser charge than kidnapping as well. 

But State attorney John Williams said that the boys were not only aware of Smith, but also active participants in the crimes. In fact, court testimony from Phillip Brewer indicated that Smith was removed from the trunk two times when the boys were present, and then placed back into the trunk.

"Until the hostage is actually released," Williams said. "The carjacking offense hasn't ended. And I think that makes sense."

The panel will have 90 days or less to make a decision on the appeal. If you would like to see the entire oral arguments you can visit http://livestream.com/DelawareSupremeCourt/events/4060829

  • Delmarvawide NewsDelmarvawide NewsMore>>

  • Videotaped Package Delivery Irks Kent County Resident

    Videotaped Package Delivery Irks Kent County Resident

    Friday, December 14 2018 7:28 PM EST2018-12-15 00:28:42 GMT
    Friday, December 14 2018 7:28 PM EST2018-12-15 00:28:42 GMT
    CHESWOLD, Del. --- Chris Walsh got an alert on Thursday from his motion-sensitive door camera after a delivery truck with a package he was expecting arrived at his house. What Walsh said he didn't expect was to see the driver fling the package onto his frMore
    CHESWOLD, Del. --- Chris Walsh got an alert on Thursday from his motion-sensitive door camera after a delivery truck with a package he was expecting arrived at his house. What Walsh said he didn't expect was to see the driver fling the package onto his frMore
  • Pinocchio the Bear Gets Special Visit from Old Ecuadorian Friends

    Pinocchio the Bear Gets Special Visit from Old Ecuadorian Friends

    Friday, December 14 2018 6:52 PM EST2018-12-14 23:52:23 GMT
    Friday, December 14 2018 6:52 PM EST2018-12-14 23:52:23 GMT
    Marco Chico and Paul Aulestia visit Pinocchio (c) WBOC 2018Marco Chico and Paul Aulestia visit Pinocchio (c) WBOC 2018
    Marco Chico and Paul Aulestia visit Pinocchio (c) WBOC 2018Marco Chico and Paul Aulestia visit Pinocchio (c) WBOC 2018
    SALISBURY, MD.- Pinocchio the Salisbury Zoo's Andean bear received a visit from his former caretakers today. "We got goosebumps when we saw him," Says Paul Aulestia one of the members of the team that rescued the bear in Ecuador years ago. "It was sad to More
    SALISBURY, MD.- Pinocchio the Salisbury Zoo's Andean bear received a visit from his former caretakers today. "We got goosebumps when we saw him," Says Paul Aulestia one of the members of the team that rescued the bear in Ecuador years ago. "It was sad to More
  • Knapps Narrows Drawbridge Causing Delays In Tilghman Island

    Knapps Narrows Drawbridge Causing Delays In Tilghman Island

    Friday, December 14 2018 6:04 PM EST2018-12-14 23:04:03 GMT
    Friday, December 14 2018 6:04 PM EST2018-12-14 23:04:03 GMT
    If you're driving in Talbot County near the Knapps Narrows Bridge, you may want to leave your house a little earlier, especially in the morning and evenings, neighbors say. That's because the bridge is opening completely now.More
    If you're driving in Talbot County near the Knapps Narrows Bridge, you may want to leave your house a little earlier, especially in the morning and evenings, neighbors say. That's because the bridge is opening completely now. More
  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Videotaped Package Delivery Irks Kent County Resident

    Videotaped Package Delivery Irks Kent County Resident

    Friday, December 14 2018 7:28 PM EST2018-12-15 00:28:42 GMT
    Friday, December 14 2018 7:28 PM EST2018-12-15 00:28:42 GMT
    CHESWOLD, Del. --- Chris Walsh got an alert on Thursday from his motion-sensitive door camera after a delivery truck with a package he was expecting arrived at his house. What Walsh said he didn't expect was to see the driver fling the package onto his frMore
    CHESWOLD, Del. --- Chris Walsh got an alert on Thursday from his motion-sensitive door camera after a delivery truck with a package he was expecting arrived at his house. What Walsh said he didn't expect was to see the driver fling the package onto his frMore
  • Police: Millsboro Man Arrested With 7,800 Bags of Heroin

    Police: Millsboro Man Arrested With 7,800 Bags of Heroin

    Friday, December 14 2018 1:28 PM EST2018-12-14 18:28:06 GMT
    Friday, December 14 2018 2:12 PM EST2018-12-14 19:12:14 GMT
    Delaware State Police say troopers arrested a Millsboro man after a traffic stop led to the discovery of approximately 7,800 bags of heroin.More
    Delaware State Police say troopers arrested a Millsboro man after a traffic stop led to the discovery of approximately 7,800 bags of heroin.More
  • Grotto Pizza to Host Rehoboth Beach Nativity Scene

    Grotto Pizza to Host Rehoboth Beach Nativity Scene

    Friday, December 14 2018 2:50 PM EST2018-12-14 19:50:54 GMT
    Friday, December 14 2018 3:13 PM EST2018-12-14 20:13:48 GMT
    Photo courtesy: Patty DerrickPhoto courtesy: Patty Derrick
    Photo courtesy: Patty DerrickPhoto courtesy: Patty Derrick
    After the City of Rehoboth Beach denied St. Edmond Catholic Church permission to place a nativity scene on city property near the bandstand, the church has found a new home for it: Grotto Pizza's downtown location on Rehoboth Avenue.More
    After the City of Rehoboth Beach denied St. Edmond Catholic Church permission to place a nativity scene on city property near the bandstand, the church has found a new home for it: Grotto Pizza's downtown location on Rehoboth Avenue. More
Powered by Frankly

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 WBOC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices