Delaware Justices Overturn Conviction in Barbershop Killings - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -

Delaware Justices Overturn Conviction in Barbershop Killings

Posted: Updated:
(Photo: MGN) (Photo: MGN)

DOVER, Del. (AP) - The Delaware Supreme Court has overturned the conviction of a death-row inmate in the fatal shootings of a man and a 5-year-old boy at a Wilmington barbershop in 2001.
    
In ruling issued this week, the justices said Chauncy Starling was entitled to a new trial because his defense attorney's mistakes and prosecutors' failure to disclose that charges against the state's key witness had been dropped before Starling's trial.
    
Starling, 40, was sentenced to death in 2004 for the killings of 5-year-old Damon Gist Jr. and Darnell Evans, 28, at the Made 4 Men barbershop in downtown Wilmington.
    
Carl Kanefsky, a spokesman for the attorney general's office, said Tuesday that prosecutors were evaluating the court's decision.
    
Defense attorney David Fragale called the killings of Evans and Gist heinous, but said Starling was not responsible.
    
"The court's decision reversing Mr. Starling's conviction is consistent with his innocence," Fragale said in an email. "There is no reliable evidence on which to retry Mr. Starling. If the state of Delaware chooses to do so anyway, we are confident that a fair trial will lead to his complete exoneration and allow Mr. Starling to return home to his family where he belongs."
    
According to court records, Starling and two other men, Alfred Gaines and Richard Frink, were searching for Evans on the day of the shooting. After spotting him, Starling entered the barbershop wearing a hooded sweat shirt and a covering over his face, and shot Evans several times, police said. As Evans tried to run, a bullet struck the child in the head.
    
In overturning Starling's conviction, the Supreme Court noted that his attorney forgot to examine an eyewitness who recalled seeing newspaper photographs of Starling and another suspect and told an investigator that neither had the same appearance as the shooter.
    
The court also noted that Starling's attorney failed to object to the admission of a statement by Starling's brother to police after several hours of interrogation that Starling said he was sorry for what he did to the boy.
    
"A substantial argument could have been made that the statement was involuntary and therefore inadmissible," Justice Collins J. Seitz Jr. wrote for the court.
    
The Supreme Court also noted that before the trial, prosecutors dismissed a warrant and probation violation charges against Gaines, the state's central witness, but told Starling's attorney at the time of trial that the charges against Gaines remained pending.
    
"Instead of providing accurate information, the state misinformed trial counsel about the status of Gaines' charges. This mistake, unintentional as it was, deprived the defense of important evidence that might have been used to attack the credibility of the state's main witness," Seitz wrote.
    
He said the errors, taken together, suggest a "reasonable probability" the case would have turned out differently without them.
    
Starling's attorneys suggested on appeal that prosecutors did Gaines a favor in return for his testimony. The probation violation charge against Gaines stemmed from an incident in which he was found with drugs after being shot by Starling less than a month after the barbershop killings.
 

  • Delmarvawide NewsDelmarvawide NewsMore>>

  • Firefly Attendee Dies After Being Found Unconscious at Festival Campground

    Woman Found Dead at Firefly Campground

    Jun 17, 2018 4:22 PM2018-06-17 20:22:00 GMT
    Sunday, June 17 2018 10:37 PM EDT2018-06-18 02:37:02 GMT
    DOVER, Del.- The Dover Police Department is investigating after a 20-year-old woman was found dead at the firefly campground. Police say around 6:30 a.m. officers were alerted to an unresponsive woman at Firefly Camping Lot 18. Police say the woman was foMore
    DOVER, Del.- The Dover Police Department is investigating after a 20-year-old woman was found dead at the firefly campground. Police say around 6:30 a.m. officers were alerted to an unresponsive woman at Firefly Camping Lot 18. Police say the woman was foMore
  • Police Chase Injures Deputy in Salisbury

    Police Chase Injures Deputy in Salisbury

    Jun 16, 2018 10:04 PM2018-06-17 02:04:00 GMT
    Saturday, June 16 2018 10:13 PM EDT2018-06-17 02:13:26 GMT
    SALISBURY, Md.- An early morning police chase led to a Parsonsburg woman behind bars and a sheriff's deputy in the hospital in Salisbury. According to the Wicomico County Sheriff's Office, around 7:30 a.m. officers were dispatched to a hit and run. WhileMore
    SALISBURY, Md.- An early morning police chase led to a Parsonsburg woman behind bars and a sheriff's deputy in the hospital in Salisbury. According to the Wicomico County Sheriff's Office, around 7:30 a.m. officers were dispatched to a hit and run. While More
  • UPDATED POST: Delaware State Police Investigating Serious Crash in Millsboro Area

    Delaware State Police Investigating Serious Crash in Millsboro Area

    Jun 16, 2018 4:05 PM2018-06-16 20:05:00 GMT
    Saturday, June 16 2018 9:55 PM EDT2018-06-17 01:55:44 GMT
    MILLSBORO, Del.- Delaware State Police are on the scene of what they are classifying as a serious accident in the Millsboro area. Police say a crash involving a motorcycle occurred at 11:51 a.m. Saturday on Route 24 near Oak Orchard Road. Police closed RoMore
    MILLSBORO, Del.- Delaware State Police are on the scene of what they are classifying as a serious accident in the Millsboro area. Police say a crash involving a motorcycle occurred at 11:51 a.m. Saturday on Route 24 near Oak Orchard Road. Police closed RoMore
  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Firefly Attendee Dies After Being Found Unconscious at Festival Campground

    Woman Found Dead at Firefly Campground

    Jun 17, 2018 4:22 PM2018-06-17 20:22:00 GMT
    Sunday, June 17 2018 10:37 PM EDT2018-06-18 02:37:02 GMT
    DOVER, Del.- The Dover Police Department is investigating after a 20-year-old woman was found dead at the firefly campground. Police say around 6:30 a.m. officers were alerted to an unresponsive woman at Firefly Camping Lot 18. Police say the woman was foMore
    DOVER, Del.- The Dover Police Department is investigating after a 20-year-old woman was found dead at the firefly campground. Police say around 6:30 a.m. officers were alerted to an unresponsive woman at Firefly Camping Lot 18. Police say the woman was foMore
  • Police Chase Injures Deputy in Salisbury

    Police Chase Injures Deputy in Salisbury

    Jun 16, 2018 10:04 PM2018-06-17 02:04:00 GMT
    Saturday, June 16 2018 10:13 PM EDT2018-06-17 02:13:26 GMT
    SALISBURY, Md.- An early morning police chase led to a Parsonsburg woman behind bars and a sheriff's deputy in the hospital in Salisbury. According to the Wicomico County Sheriff's Office, around 7:30 a.m. officers were dispatched to a hit and run. WhileMore
    SALISBURY, Md.- An early morning police chase led to a Parsonsburg woman behind bars and a sheriff's deputy in the hospital in Salisbury. According to the Wicomico County Sheriff's Office, around 7:30 a.m. officers were dispatched to a hit and run. While More
  • Salisbury Fire Department Recovers Car in River

    Salisbury Fire Department Recovers Car in River

    Jun 17, 2018 4:01 PM2018-06-17 20:01:00 GMT
    Sunday, June 17 2018 4:02 PM EDT2018-06-17 20:02:40 GMT
    SALISBURY, Md.- The Salisbury Fire Department spent Sunday morning recovering a partially submerged car in the Wicomico River. According to the fire department, firefighters were dispatched to the river near Market Street Inn around 11:30 a.m. Once on sceMore
    SALISBURY, Md.- The Salisbury Fire Department spent Sunday morning recovering a partially submerged car in the Wicomico River. According to the fire department, firefighters were dispatched to the river near Market Street Inn around 11:30 a.m. Once on sceMore
  • Most Popular VideosMost Popular VideosMore>>

  • Watch: Former Cape May Ferry Sunk for Use as Artificial Reef

    Watch: Former Cape May Ferry Sunk for Use as Artificial Reef

    On Friday, a former Cape May-Lewes ferry was sunk to become part of Delaware’s artificial reef system. The Twin Capes joined the Del-Jersey-Land reef’s submerged fleet that includes the ex-destroyer USS Arthur W. Radford, which went down in 2011 as the longest ship reefed on the East Coast, and the Zuni/Tamaroa, a Battle of Iwo Jima survivor turned US Coast Guard cutter that plied Atlantic waters for nearly 50 years.

    More

    On Friday, a former Cape May-Lewes ferry was sunk to become part of Delaware’s artificial reef system. The Twin Capes joined the Del-Jersey-Land reef’s submerged fleet that includes the ex-destroyer USS Arthur W. Radford, which went down in 2011 as the longest ship reefed on the East Coast, and the Zuni/Tamaroa, a Battle of Iwo Jima survivor turned US Coast Guard cutter that plied Atlantic waters for nearly 50 years.

    More
  • Ocean City's "Boardwalk Elvis" Passes Away

    Ocean City's "Boardwalk Elvis" Passes Away

    A man who delighted Ocean City crowds as "Boardwalk Elvis" has passed away. Norman Webb died Saturday after a battle with cancer. Webb roamed the boardwalk for decades dressed up as "the King." Webb would also sing Elvis songs in costume as well. A few weeks before his passing, Webb was awarded a key to Ocean City. Webb was 78 years old.

    More

    A man who delighted Ocean City crowds as "Boardwalk Elvis" has passed away. Norman Webb died Saturday after a battle with cancer. Webb roamed the boardwalk for decades dressed up as "the King." Webb would also sing Elvis songs in costume as well. A few weeks before his passing, Webb was awarded a key to Ocean City. Webb was 78 years old.

    More
  • Ocean City Air Show Takes Off

    Ocean City Air Show Takes Off

    The 11th Annual Ocean City Air Show took flight this weekend! And this year's show was all about honoring the military. WBOC's Caroline Coles shows us some of the high-flying stunts, and the crowd's excitement!
    More
    The 11th Annual Ocean City Air Show took flight this weekend! And this year's show was all about honoring the military. WBOC's Caroline Coles shows us some of the high-flying stunts, and the crowd's excitement!
    More
Powered by Frankly

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 WBOC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices