Ex-judge Fined $5,000 for Ordering Defendant Shocked - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -

Ex-judge Fined $5,000 for Ordering Defendant Shocked

Posted: Updated:

GREENBELT, Md. (AP)- A former Maryland judge who ordered a defendant to be physically shocked in his courtroom was sentenced Thursday to participate in anger-management classes and pay a $5,000 fine.
    
Robert C. Nalley of La Plata, Maryland, will also have to spend a year on probation. Nalley, 72, pleaded guilty earlier this year to a civil rights violation for ordering a deputy to activate a "stun-cuff" that a defendant appearing before him was wearing around his ankle. The defendant, who was acting as his own lawyer, was before Nalley in July 2014 for jury selection and had failed to listen to Nalley's orders to stop speaking.
    
After he was shocked, the defendant fell to the ground screaming. A video of the exchange without sound and separate audio was played in court Thursday. Prosecutor Kristi O'Malley noted that the defendant didn't raise his voice or yell during the exchange and even called the judge "sir." She said Nalley "very quickly grew impatient" and that his use of the stun-cuff was "highly disproportionate" for "nothing more than verbal interruptions."
    
"Our constitution does not allow a violation of rights based on annoyance," she said.
    
Nalley acknowledged as part of a plea deal "that the use of the stun cuff was objectively unreasonable under the circumstances," and both prosecutors and Nalley's lawyer agreed to recommend a sentence of one year on probation.
    
"To say that I'm chagrinned to be standing here is an understatement," Nalley said in a brief statement in federal court in Greenbelt on Thursday.
    
Nalley, who was a judge in Charles County from 1988 to September 2014, did not apologize in court but did say he had made an "error in judgment." Nalley's ability to hear cases was rescinded several months after the incident.
    
Judge William Connelly, who oversaw Nalley's case, said in court that a year of probation was an appropriate sentence in part because of Nalley's age and the fact he can no longer hear cases.
    
Also in court Thursday was the defendant Nalley ordered shocked, Saamir Jhaled Khaleel Kingali, who at the time he was before Nalley was charged with unlawful possession of a firearm. Kingali, 27, who is also referred to in court records as Delvon King, called Nalley's actions "torture" and a "very dehumanizing experience" and walked out of the courtroom before Nalley was sentenced.
    
"There was no justice here today," he said after the hearing, adding that he doesn't believe Nalley is sorry for his actions.
    
The stun-cuff administered an electric shock for about five seconds. Kingali said the shock had impacted his ability to act as his own lawyer when his trial resumed.
    
Nalley's lawyer, Robert Bonsib, noted in a court filing ahead of Thursday's hearing that Kingali had a history of disruptive courtroom behavior, including previously running out of the courthouse. He said Nalley had been warned of Kingali's disruptive behavior already on the day of the incident. And before Nalley ordered Kingali to stop speaking the two had also struggled over the name Kingali should be called in court. Bonsib also said Nalley had never been trained on the use of the stun-cuff.
    
This is not the first time Nalley has been a defendant. In 2010, he pleaded guilty to tampering with a vehicle after he deflated the tire of a cleaning woman's car that was parked in a restricted zone at the courthouse. As a result, he was fined, had to write a letter of apology and was suspended for five days without pay.

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Updated: Teen Killed in Wicomico County Crash Identified

    Updated: Teen Killed in Wicomico County Crash Identified

    Monday, September 24 2018 10:26 PM EDT2018-09-25 02:26:13 GMT
    Tuesday, September 25 2018 3:52 PM EDT2018-09-25 19:52:38 GMT
    (Image: MGN)(Image: MGN)
    (Image: MGN)(Image: MGN)
    A Wicomico County Public Schools official has identified a 17-year-old girl killed in a Monday afternoon car crash.More
    A Wicomico County Public Schools official has identified a 17-year-old girl killed in a Monday afternoon car crash.More
  • 16 Mile Brewery Shuts Down

    16 Mile Brewery Shuts Down

    Monday, September 24 2018 4:45 PM EDT2018-09-24 20:45:11 GMT
    Tuesday, September 25 2018 7:45 AM EDT2018-09-25 11:45:03 GMT
    GEORGETOWN, Del.- After speculation late last week, 16 Mile Brewery has officially closed its doors. On Monday, the local brewery's LED sign on Bedford Street read "Thank you for a great decade." The brewery's doors were locked, the lights off, and a signMore
    GEORGETOWN, Del.- After speculation late last week, 16 Mile Brewery has officially closed its doors. On Monday, the local brewery's LED sign on Bedford Street read "Thank you for a great decade." The brewery's doors were locked, the lights off, and a signMore
  • Health Officials: 50 People May Have Been Exposed to TB at Georgetown Elementary

    Health Officials: 50 People May Have Been Exposed to TB at Georgetown Elementary

    Tuesday, September 25 2018 11:47 AM EDT2018-09-25 15:47:33 GMT
    Tuesday, September 25 2018 3:45 PM EDT2018-09-25 19:45:11 GMT
    Credit: WBOCCredit: WBOC
    Credit: WBOCCredit: WBOC
    The Delaware Division of Public Health and the Indian River School District announced Tuesday that approximately 50 individuals at Georgetown Elementary School may have been exposed to someone with active tuberculosis.More
    The Delaware Division of Public Health and the Indian River School District announced Tuesday that approximately 50 individuals at Georgetown Elementary School may have been exposed to someone with active tuberculosis. More
  • Most Popular VideosMost Popular VideosMore>>

  • 16 Mile Brewery Shuts Down

    16 Mile Brewery Shuts Down

    After speculation late last week, 16 Mile Brewery has officially closed its doors.

    On Monday, the local brewery's LED sign on Bedford Street read "Thank you for a great decade." The brewery's doors were locked, the lights off, and a sign read "CLOSED. We appreciated your business and are sorry to inform you that we have decided to close 16 Mile Brewery and Tavern indefinitely. Thank you for your patronage and support over the last 9 years."

    More

    After speculation late last week, 16 Mile Brewery has officially closed its doors.

    On Monday, the local brewery's LED sign on Bedford Street read "Thank you for a great decade." The brewery's doors were locked, the lights off, and a sign read "CLOSED. We appreciated your business and are sorry to inform you that we have decided to close 16 Mile Brewery and Tavern indefinitely. Thank you for your patronage and support over the last 9 years."

    More
  • Police Investigating Deadly Crash in Wicomico County

    Police Investigating Deadly Crash in Wicomico County

    Maryland State Police are investigating a deadly car crash Friday afternoon. It happened at the intersection of White Lowe Road and Route 50 shortly before 3 p.m. According to MSP, Maria Theresia Ellis, 77 of Ocean City, was driving on White Lowe Road when her car failed to yield to oncoming traffic as she turned onto Route 50. Police said Ellis's car was hit in a T-bone like manner by Garrett Adrian Pusey, 20 of Mardela Springs.

    More

    Maryland State Police are investigating a deadly car crash Friday afternoon. It happened at the intersection of White Lowe Road and Route 50 shortly before 3 p.m. According to MSP, Maria Theresia Ellis, 77 of Ocean City, was driving on White Lowe Road when her car failed to yield to oncoming traffic as she turned onto Route 50. Police said Ellis's car was hit in a T-bone like manner by Garrett Adrian Pusey, 20 of Mardela Springs.

    More
  • Confusing Street Signs Come to Dewey Beach

    Confusing Street Signs Come to Dewey Beach

    New street signs are popping up in Dewey Beach, and some aren't happy about it.

    These new directional signs, Delaware's Department of Transportation says, were implemented to prevent crashes along Route 1.

    But some say it's done the opposite of helping and has created more confusion.

    More

    New street signs are popping up in Dewey Beach, and some aren't happy about it.

    These new directional signs, Delaware's Department of Transportation says, were implemented to prevent crashes along Route 1.

    But some say it's done the opposite of helping and has created more confusion.

    More
Powered by Frankly

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 WBOC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices