Updated: Delaware Court Says State Death Penalty Law Unconstitut - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -

Updated: Delaware Court Says State Death Penalty Law Unconstitutional

Posted: Updated:
(Photo: MGN) (Photo: MGN)

DOVER, Del. (AP)- Delaware's death penalty law is unconstitutional in light of a U.S. Supreme Court ruling earlier this year, the state's high court ruled Tuesday.
    
In a 148-page opinion, a majority of Delaware Supreme Court justices said the state law violates the U.S. Constitution because it allows a judge to sentence a person to death independently of a jury's recommendation.
    
The court said the law is unconstitutional because it allows a judge, independently of the jury, to find the existence of one or more aggravating circumstances weighing in favor of the death penalty, and because it does not require jurors to be unanimous in deciding whether any aggravating circumstances exist. The justices said the law is also flawed because it allows the judge, not the jury, to make the crucial final determination on whether aggravating circumstances outweigh mitigating factors, thus mandating a death sentence. That determination, the court said, must be made unanimously and beyond a reasonable doubt by the jury.
    
"If the right to a jury means anything, it means the right to have a jury drawn from the community and acting as a proxy for its diverse views and mores, rather than one judge, make the awful decision whether the defendant should live or die," wrote Chief Justice Leo Strine Jr.
    
Justice Karen Valihura concurred in part with the majority opinion but issued a partial dissent regarding jury unanimity and whether the weighing of aggravating and mitigating circumstances must be done by a jury instead of a judge.
    
Meanwhile, Justice James Vaughn Jr. dissented in full from his colleagues, noting an important difference between Delaware's law and a similar Florida sentencing scheme that was struck down by the U.S. Supreme Court. Unlike under the Florida law, Vaughn said, a person in Delaware is not eligible for the death penalty until and unless a jury finds unanimously and beyond a reasonable doubt the existence of at least one specific statutory aggravating factor.
    
"I am satisfied that Delaware's death penalty statute complies with the Sixth Amendment as the law on that amendment is currently interpreted by the U.S. Supreme Court," Vaughn wrote.
    
The justice agreed, however, that any problematic provision of Delaware's death penalty law cannot be severed from its other provisions so as to allow jury instructions that would comport with federal constitutional standards.
    
"Because the respective roles of the judge and jury are so complicated ..., we are unable to discern a method by which to parse the statute so as to preserve it," the court said, adding that any decision about reinstating the death penalty should be left to the General Assembly, where attempts by death penalty opponents to abolish capital punishment have repeatedly failed.
    
Gov. Jack Markell praised Tuesday's court ruling, describing capital punishment as "an instrument of imperfect justice" that does not make society safer.
    
"While I would have supported abolishing the death penalty legislatively, it is my hope that today's decision will mean that we never see another death sentence in our state," Markell said in a prepared statement.
    
Santino Ceccotti, a lawyer with the Delaware public defender's office who argued the case before the Supreme Court, said he was pleased with the ruling but noted the state attorney general's office could appeal the decision in federal court. A spokeswoman for the Delaware Department of Justice said in an email that the agency is reviewing the decision.
    
Ceccotti said it remains to be seen whether the ruling could be applied retroactively to the 13 men currently on Delaware's death row.
    
"What we know for sure is that the scheme in Delaware is unconstitutional ... and that will have a direct impact on cases that are pending," he said.
    
Ceccotti said all defendants in cases in which prosecutors are seeking the death penalty will have to be recharged.
    
"With this decision, capital murder is no longer an option," he said.

  • Delmarvawide NewsDelmarvawide NewsMore>>

  • Major Road Paving Work Set to Begin in Wicomico County

    Major Road Paving Work Set to Begin in Wicomico County

    Tuesday, July 25 2017 2:17 PM EDT2017-07-25 18:17:06 GMT
    Tuesday, July 25 2017 2:17 PM EDT2017-07-25 18:17:06 GMT
    Wicomico County has budgeted $4.5 million for repaving county roads in fiscal year 2018. Preparation for the work began July 1, and a majority of the work is expected to begin this fall.More
    Wicomico County has budgeted $4.5 million for repaving county roads in fiscal year 2018. Preparation for the work began July 1, and a majority of the work is expected to begin this fall.More
  • Symposium Tackles Opioid Epidemic in Salisbury

    Symposium Tackles Opioid Epidemic in Salisbury

    07/18/2017 17:38:00 -04:002017-07-18 21:38:00 GMT
    Tuesday, July 18 2017 5:38 PM EDT2017-07-18 21:38:46 GMT
    A panel of community leaders held an opioid and addiction coalition at Salisbury University (Photo: WBOC)A panel of community leaders held an opioid and addiction coalition at Salisbury University (Photo: WBOC)
    SALISBURY, Md.-- The spotlight was shown today on the growing opioid epidemic taking place across Delmarva. A regional opioid and addiction coalition held a symposium at Salisbury University to talk about treatments and possible recovery initiatives.CommMore
    SALISBURY, Md.-- The spotlight was shown today on the growing opioid epidemic taking place across Delmarva. A regional opioid and addiction coalition held a symposium at Salisbury University to talk about treatments and possible recovery initiatives.CommMore
  • Crowds Flock to 41st Annual Tawes Crab and Clam Bake in Crisfield

    Crowds Flock to 41st Annual Tawes Crab and Clam Bake in Crisfield

    07/19/2017 13:23:00 -04:002017-07-19 17:23:00 GMT
    Wednesday, July 19 2017 2:50 PM EDT2017-07-19 18:50:17 GMT
    (Photo: WBOC)(Photo: WBOC)
    The Crisfield Area Chamber of Commerce hosted the city's 41st annual J. Millard Tawes Crab & Clam Bake Wednesday afternoon.More
    The Crisfield Area Chamber of Commerce hosted the city's 41st annual J. Millard Tawes Crab & Clam Bake Wednesday afternoon.More
  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Dead Shark Washes up on OC Beach

    Dead Shark Washes up on OC Beach

    07/25/2017 07:38:00 -04:002017-07-25 11:38:00 GMT
    Tuesday, July 25 2017 7:39 AM EDT2017-07-25 11:39:19 GMT
    This shark washed ashore in Ocean City on Monday. (Photo credit: Lloyd Fox/Baltimore Sun)This shark washed ashore in Ocean City on Monday. (Photo credit: Lloyd Fox/Baltimore Sun)
    Some beach goers in Ocean City got quite a surprise Monday when a large shark washed ashore.More
    Some beach goers in Ocean City, Maryland got quite a surprise Monday when a large shark washed ashore.More
  • Salisbury Man Sentenced to 25 Years After Third Felony Drug Conviction

    Salisbury Man Sentenced to 25 Years After Third Felony Drug Conviction

    Thursday, July 23 2015 12:15 PM EDT2015-07-23 16:15:04 GMT
    Thursday, July 23 2015 12:48 PM EDT2015-07-23 16:48:44 GMT
    A Salisbury man convicted last month of cocaine possession and “maintaining a common nuisance” has been sentenced to 25 years without parole, the Wicomico County State's Attorney's Office announced Thursday.More
    A Salisbury man convicted last month of cocaine possession and “maintaining a common nuisance” has been sentenced to 25 years without parole, the Wicomico County State's Attorney's Office announced Thursday.More
  • Assateague Horse Died After Eating Dog Food

    Assateague Horse Died After Eating Dog Food

    07/24/2017 15:45:00 -04:002017-07-24 19:45:00 GMT
    Monday, July 24 2017 3:57 PM EDT2017-07-24 19:57:23 GMT
    A photo of the mare that died after eating dog food at Assateague Island National Seashore. (Photo credit: L. Davis/Assateague Island National Seashore)A photo of the mare that died after eating dog food at Assateague Island National Seashore. (Photo credit: L. Davis/Assateague Island National Seashore)
    Officials say a wild horse was found dead after eating a large amount of dog food at Assateague Island National Seashore.More
    Officials say a wild horse was found dead after eating a large amount of dog food at Assateague Island National Seashore.More
  • Most Popular VideosMost Popular VideosMore>>

  • Tornado Destroys Homes in Stevensville

    Tornado Destroys Homes in Stevensville

    Several homes in the Bay City area of Stevensville were left extremely damaged after a tornado.

    More

    Several homes in the Bay City area of Stevensville were left extremely damaged after a tornado.

    More
  • Damage, Power Outages Reported in Queen Anne's Co. After Severe Weather

    Damage, Power Outages Reported in Queen Anne's Co. After Severe Weather

    A National Weather Service team is headed to Maryland's Eastern Shore to determine whether a tornado touched down there.

    The weather service says the team is headed to Queen Anne's County on Monday to assess damage from the early morning storm that downed trees, collapsed buildings and knocked out power to thousands overnight in the Stevensville area of Kent Island. County officials say one person was injured but those injuries were not life-threatening.

    More

    A National Weather Service team is headed to Maryland's Eastern Shore to determine whether a tornado touched down there.

    The weather service says the team is headed to Queen Anne's County on Monday to assess damage from the early morning storm that downed trees, collapsed buildings and knocked out power to thousands overnight in the Stevensville area of Kent Island. County officials say one person was injured but those injuries were not life-threatening.

    More
  • People of Cambridge Move on From Segregated Past

    People of Cambridge Move on From Segregated Past

    Fifty years ago, civil unrest in Cambridge reached a boiling point. Now fifty years later, people say they are ready to reflect on those times and to move forward.

    More

    Fifty years ago, civil unrest in Cambridge reached a boiling point. Now fifty years later, people say they are ready to reflect on those times and to move forward.

    More
Powered by Frankly

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2017 WBOC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices