Case Challenging Maryland Congressional Districts Moving Forward - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -

Case Challenging Maryland Congressional Districts Moving Forward

Posted: Updated:

WASHINGTON (AP)- A lawsuit challenging a 2011 redrawing of Maryland's congressional districts that enabled Democrats to pick up an additional seat in Congress can go forward, a three-judge panel ruled Wednesday.
    
The panel ruled 2-1 that the case can continue. State officials had argued that it should be dismissed.
    
The U.S. Supreme Court ruled in the case late last year, saying it had been improperly dismissed at an early stage. The court said federal law required that the case be heard by a panel of three judges, not the lone judge who initially dismissed the challenge.
    
The case began in 2013 when three residents sued, arguing that the new district map was irrational and violated their First Amendment and other rights. The case now includes nine Maryland residents who argue that state officials violated their rights by redrawing the district maps with the purpose of diluting the power of Republican voters.
    
In particular, the plaintiffs point to the redrawing of the state's sixth congressional district, which was represented for 20 years by Republican Roscoe Bartlett. The residents argue that in 2011, after the 2010 census, Democratic Gov. Martin O'Malley and Democratic-controlled legislature set out to make the district a Democratic one. After the re-drawing, Bartlett faced Democrat John Delaney in his 2012 bid for re-election and lost to the Democrat. Seven of the state's eight representatives to Congress are Democrats.
    
The Supreme Court has suggested that extreme political gerrymandering would in theory violate the Constitution but it has struggled to come up with a standard for when it goes too far. The court has also suggested the judicial system may not be the right place for a challenge.
    
In allowing the case to go forward, Judge Paul Niemeyer wrote for himself and Judge George Levi Russell III that the facts of the case "support a plausible claim" that the residents' rights were violated.
    
Michael B. Kimberly, the attorney representing the Maryland residents, called Wednesday's ruling "satisfying."
    
"Finally we have a theory where they might step in and say enough is enough," to political gerrymandering, he said.
    
The next step in the case is a trial before the three-judge panel, but that is unlikely to happen before December, Kimberly said.
    
The third judge hearing the case, Judge James K. Bredar, wrote that he would have granted the state's motion to dismiss. He was the judge who initially dismissed the case himself before the Supreme Court ordered the hearing by a three-judge panel.
    
"Because I conclude that Plaintiffs' claims can never succeed, I would spare the parties the significant expense of discovery and end this case now. Offensive as political gerrymandering may be, there is nothing to be gained (and much to be lost) in postponing the inevitable," Bredar wrote.
    
Bredar and Russell were both nominated by a Democrat, President Barack Obama. Niemeyer was nominated to his current position by a Republican, George H.W. Bush.

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Police Looking for Driver Involved in Pedestrian Hit-And-Run Crash

    Police Looking for Driver Involved in Pedestrian Hit-And-Run Crash

    Monday, October 15 2018 8:56 PM EDT2018-10-16 00:56:06 GMT
    Monday, October 15 2018 8:56 PM EDT2018-10-16 00:56:06 GMT
    The Milford Police Department is asking for the public's help in finding a driver who police say hit a pedestrian and drove off.More
    The Milford Police Department is asking for the public's help in finding a driver who police say hit a pedestrian and drove off. More
  • Nanticoke Road Closure in Wicomico County

    Nanticoke Road Closure in Wicomico County

    Monday, October 15 2018 5:19 PM EDT2018-10-15 21:19:28 GMT
    Monday, October 15 2018 5:19 PM EDT2018-10-15 21:19:28 GMT
    Nanticoke Road (Photo WBOC)Nanticoke Road (Photo WBOC)
    Nanticoke Road (Photo WBOC)Nanticoke Road (Photo WBOC)
    A part of Nanticoke Road is closed for a significant period of time due to part of the road collapsing. The State Highway Administration is working around the clock to make the necessary repairs.More
    A part of Nanticoke Road is closed for a significant period of time due to part of the road collapsing. The State Highway Administration is working around the clock to make the necessary repairs. More
  • Power Outages Scheduled in Lewes

    Power Outages Scheduled in Lewes

    Monday, October 15 2018 6:48 PM EDT2018-10-15 22:48:30 GMT
    Monday, October 15 2018 6:48 PM EDT2018-10-15 22:48:30 GMT
    A series of scheduled power outages will take place in Lewes this week.More
    A series of scheduled power outages will take place in Lewes this week.More
  • Most Popular VideosMost Popular VideosMore>>

  • "Hood Fight Salisbury" Cell Phone Videos

    "Hood Fight Salisbury" Cell Phone Videos

    27 cell phone videos depicting brutal streets fights among teenagers in Salisbury were posted online. Local leaders including the Mayor, State's Attorney and a Reverend react to the media.More
    27 cell phone videos depicting brutal streets fights among teenagers in Salisbury were posted online. Local leaders including the Mayor, State's Attorney and a Reverend react to the media.More
  • Nanticoke Road Closure in Wicomico County

    Nanticoke Road Closure in Wicomico County

    It wasn't more than two years ago when a part of Nanticoke road was destroyed due to a damaged drain pipe. 

    Now, it is happening again. 

    As thousands of gallons of water are being relocated from one side of the Rockawalkin Creek to the other - the road remains closed for a significant period of time. 

    More

    It wasn't more than two years ago when a part of Nanticoke road was destroyed due to a damaged drain pipe. 

    Now, it is happening again. 

    As thousands of gallons of water are being relocated from one side of the Rockawalkin Creek to the other - the road remains closed for a significant period of time. 

    More
  • Crisfield Science Teacher named Maryland's 'Teacher of the Year'

    Crisfield Science Teacher named Maryland's 'Teacher of the Year'

    Crisfield High School is celebrating today. Dr. Richard Warren, a Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math teacher at the high school, is Maryland's teacher of the year.

    More

    Crisfield High School is celebrating today. Dr. Richard Warren, a Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math teacher at the high school, is Maryland's teacher of the year.

    More
Powered by Frankly

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 WBOC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices