Ruling Loosens Ban on Owning Guns After Minor Convictions - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -

Ruling Loosens Ban on Owning Guns After Minor Convictions

Posted: Updated:
(Photo: WBOC) (Photo: WBOC)

HARRISBURG, Pa. (AP)- A federal appeals court has ruled that some people convicted of comparatively minor state crimes should get a chance to legally own guns, issuing a divided decision that reshapes longstanding rules.
    
The narrowly divided 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Wednesday sided with two Pennsylvania residents, deeming their crimes as minor even though they could have produced jail time of more than two years.
    
The court restored gun ownership rights to Daniel Binderup, who pleaded guilty in Pennsylvania in 1998 to misdemeanor corruption of minors for a consensual sexual relationship with a 17-year-old girl working at his bakery. He received probation and a fine, but the offense carried a potential sentence of five years.
    
It also ruled in favor of Julio Suarez, who pleaded guilty in Maryland to misdemeanor possession of a handgun without a license, a conviction that could have sent him to jail for three years. He received a suspended sentence and a fine.
    
The 3rd Circuit majority ruled that the federal gun ownership ban requires the offenses to be considered serious crimes, rather than simply carry state sentences of at least two years or more. The judges noted that both Pennsylvania and Maryland graded Binderup and Suarez's conviction as misdemeanors.
    
"With not a single day of jail time, the punishments here reflect the sentencing judges' assessment of how minor the violations were," wrote U.S. Circuit Judge Thomas Ambro.
    
He said the U.S. attorney's office made claims that Suarez is likely to misuse firearms as a "potentially irresponsible" person and that Binderup was likely to commit crimes in the future, but the judge said "neither the evidence in the record nor common sense supports those assertions."
    
In a separate opinion, U.S. Circuit Judge Thomas Hardiman said that there has long been a public understanding that gun ownership rights under the Second Amendment can be taken away from people who "demonstrated that they would present a danger to the public if armed."
    
"The government has presented no evidence that either Binderup or Suarez has been, or would be, dangerous, violent, or irresponsible with firearms," Hardiman wrote.
    
A dissent from U.S. Circuit Judge Julio Fuentes said Congress has the right to deny gun ownership to people convicted of crimes, and that a potential sentence of more than two years means a crime constitutes a serious offense.
    
"Binderup and Suarez are, in effect, saying, 'Trust us: we are not the kind of people who will cause future gun violence,'" Fuentes wrote. "The problem is that it is practically impossible to make this kind of individualized prediction with any degree of confidence. Mistakes - costly ones - are simply too likely."
    
Messages seeking comment from the men's attorneys and the Justice Department were not immediately returned.

  • Delmarvawide NewsDelmarvawide NewsMore>>

  • Downtown Dover Parking Study to be Released This Week

    Downtown Dover Parking Study to be Released This Week

    08/21/2017 20:06:00 -04:002017-08-22 00:06:00 GMT
    Monday, August 21 2017 8:06 PM EDT2017-08-22 00:06:02 GMT
    DOVER, Del. -- Findings on a study about parking in Downtown Dover are set to be discussed at a public meeting this week.The Dover/Kent County Metropolitan Planning Organization's council is set to focus on the study during a meeting on TMore
    DOVER, Del. -- Findings on a study about parking in Downtown Dover are set to be discussed at a public meeting this week.The Dover/Kent County Metropolitan Planning Organization's council is set to focus on the study during a meeting on TMore
  • Sky High Solar Eclipse Celebration in Sussex County

    Sky High Solar Eclipse Celebration in Sussex County

    08/21/2017 18:54:00 -04:002017-08-21 22:54:00 GMT
    Monday, August 21 2017 6:59 PM EDT2017-08-21 22:59:14 GMT
    INDIAN RIVER INLET, Del. - Delaware Seashore State Park held a viewing party at the Indian River Inlet bridge during Monday's solar eclipse.People lined up as early as 9:30 a.m. to purchase glasses that went on sale at 1:00 p.m, and by the afternoon, theMore
    INDIAN RIVER INLET, Del. - Delaware Seashore State Park held a viewing party at the Indian River Inlet bridge during Monday's solar eclipse.People lined up as early as 9:30 a.m. to purchase glasses that went on sale at 1:00 p.m, and by the afternoon, theMore
  • Recovery Homes Popping Up in Talbot County

    More Recovery Homes Popping Up in Talbot County

    08/21/2017 18:13:00 -04:002017-08-21 22:13:00 GMT
    Monday, August 21 2017 6:14 PM EDT2017-08-21 22:14:36 GMT
    It looks like any other home in Easton, but the Humble House is more than that - it's a sanctuary.More
    It looks like any other home in Easton, but the Humble House is more than that - it's a sanctuary.More
Powered by Frankly

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2017 WBOC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices