Motion To Deny Polygraph Test Results In White Marlin Open Case - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -

Motion To Deny Polygraph Test Results In White Marlin Open Case Denied

Posted: Updated:

A federal court judge Friday essentially decided that polygraph test results following the White Marlin Open fishing tournament can be used in the ongoing legal case.

Back in August, Phil Heasley, from Florida, caught a 76.5 pound white marlin, making him the winner of $2.8 million dollars in prize money.

Tournament officials, though, said Heasley and his crew failed the post-tournament lie detector tests regarding tournament rules, which disqualified him as the winner. It also meant Heasley would not receive the prize money. Instead, the money would be divvied up among thirteen other anglers.

White Marlin Open officials filed a Complaint for Interpleader, essentially asking a judge to decide if in fact tournament rules were broken, and if so, how the prize much should be dispersed.  Heasley filed a motion asking The polygraph results be thrown out, arguing that since White Marlin Open officials asked a court to determine if Heasley was eligible for the prize money, White Marlin Open abandoned the process for determining a winner based on its rules, thus invalidating the use of the polygraph results. Judge Richard D. Bennett denied that motion Friday.
 

Christopher P. Sullivan, Heasley's attorney, released a statement Friday saying, "Philip Heasley and his crew followed the rules of the tournament to the letter.  They even contacted tournament staff during the tournament to ensure their actions would not violate tournament procedures.  As he stated in his affidavit, Heasley and his crew also fully cooperated with the tournament officials’ questioning as part of the investigation following their first prize finish.  When they learned of the tournament’s concerns, they reasonably expected to have the opportunity to defend themselves.  Instead, the tournament never allowed them this opportunity and instead filed a lawsuit against Mr. Heasley.  Heasley and his crew will show through boat records, eyewitness accounts and other strong evidence that the tournament’s allegations are false and that he is the rightful winner of the White Marlin Open.” 

Judge Bennett also decided the case will stay in federal court in Baltimore, as opposed to returning to Worcester County.
Attorneys in the case now have ten days to tell the judge when they will be ready for trial. a trial date will be then presumably be set.

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Sussex County Drug Unit Arrests 14 in Drug Investigation

    Sussex County Drug Unit Arrests 14 in Drug Investigation

    08/23/2017 13:29:00 -04:002017-08-23 17:29:00 GMT
    Wednesday, August 23 2017 1:41 PM EDT2017-08-23 17:41:30 GMT
    Janie Handy, Jayquan Bland, Delane Jacobs; DSPDJanie Handy, Jayquan Bland, Delane Jacobs; DSPD
    SELBYVILLE AND FRANKFORD, Del.-- The Delaware State Police Sussex County Drug Unit has charged fourteen people following a three-month long drug investigation in the Pollybranch area of Selbyville.On Tuesday, DSP along with investigators from seven otherMore
    SELBYVILLE AND FRANKFORD, Del.-- The Delaware State Police Sussex County Drug Unit has charged fourteen people following a three-month long drug investigation in the Pollybranch area of Selbyville.More
  • Trial Nears for Alleged Leader of Delaware Criminal Network

    Trial Nears for Alleged Leader of Delaware Criminal Network

    Wednesday, August 23 2017 4:48 AM EDT2017-08-23 08:48:13 GMT
    Wednesday, August 23 2017 4:48 AM EDT2017-08-23 08:48:13 GMT
    Steven Kellam (Photo: Delaware State Police)Steven Kellam (Photo: Delaware State Police)
    A judge is holding a final case review in the prosecution of the alleged ringleader of an organized crime gang that operated in central and southern Delaware.More
    A judge is holding a final case review in the prosecution of the alleged ringleader of an organized crime gang that operated in central and southern Delaware.More
  • Following Lawsuit & Financial Turmoil, 2017 Punkin Chunkin Canceled

    Following Lawsuit & Financial Turmoil, 2017 Punkin Chunkin Canceled

    08/23/2017 11:33:00 -04:002017-08-23 15:33:00 GMT
    Wednesday, August 23 2017 11:33 AM EDT2017-08-23 15:33:27 GMT
    With less than 74 days until its annual event, The World Punkin Chunkin Association announced the 2017 Punkin Chunkin has been canceled following a series of financial turmoil and a lawsuit filed against the organization.More
    With less than 74 days until its annual event, The World Punkin Chunkin Association announced the 2017 Punkin Chunkin has been canceled following a series of financial turmoil and a lawsuit filed against the organization.More
  • Most Popular VideosMost Popular VideosMore>>

  • Neighbors React to Easton Recovery Home

    Neighbors React to Easton Recovery Home

    The Humble House has some neighbors like Michael Engels more than just worried.

    "The last thing I want to do is to find out there's a halfway house within walking distance from where my children will be playing and living," Engels said.

    Upset with what's just down the street, Engels says he's considering moving.

    More

    The Humble House has some neighbors like Michael Engels more than just worried.

    "The last thing I want to do is to find out there's a halfway house within walking distance from where my children will be playing and living," Engels said.

    Upset with what's just down the street, Engels says he's considering moving.

    More
  • Scheduled Jet to Land at Salisbury Airport Tuesday, Part 3

    Scheduled Jet to Land at Salisbury Airport Tuesday, Part 3

    It took more than two decades to get to the Salisbury Wicomico Airport to where it is. WBOC's Chris Weimer spoke with former airport manager Bob Bryant about the history of the airport's expansion.

    More

    It took more than two decades to get to the Salisbury Wicomico Airport to where it is. WBOC's Chris Weimer spoke with former airport manager Bob Bryant about the history of the airport's expansion.

    More
  • Following Lawsuit & Financial Turmoil, 2017 Punkin Chunkin Canceled

    Following Lawsuit & Financial Turmoil, 2017 Punkin Chunkin Canceled

    With less than 74 days until its annual event, The World Punkin Chunkin Association announced the 2017 Punkin Chunkin has been canceled following a series of financial issues and a lawsuit filed against the organization.

    More

    With less than 74 days until its annual event, The World Punkin Chunkin Association announced the 2017 Punkin Chunkin has been canceled following a series of financial issues and a lawsuit filed against the organization.

    More
Powered by Frankly

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2017 WBOC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices