Attorney Dispute Raises Questions About Delaware Ethics Oversigh - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -

Attorney Dispute Raises Questions About Delaware Ethics Oversight

Posted: 11/10/2017 14:26:00 -05:00 Updated:

DOVER, Del. (AP)- A Superior Court judge has been asked to decide whether the public agency that oversees government ethics and the code of conduct for Delaware officials has jurisdiction over employees of the state's court system.

Judge Ferris Wharton is weighing a decision after hearing arguments this week in a case pitting a Hockessin lawyer against Delaware's Public Integrity Commission.

Attorney Rich Abbott is challenging the commission's ruling last year that it had no jurisdiction to consider a complaint he filed against the head of the Office of Disciplinary Counsel, or ODC, an arm of the Supreme Court that investigates and prosecutes allegations of lawyer misconduct.

Abbott claims that Jennifer-Kate Aaronson violated a prohibition on state employees demonstrating even the "appearance of impropriety" by refusing to recuse herself from an investigation of him that he describes as a "fishing expedition."

The commission dismissed the complaint last year for lack of jurisdiction and failure to properly allege a violation of the code of conduct. It noted that although Aaronson is a state employee, the judicial branch is vested with primary authority to enforce rules governing attorney conduct.

In a supplemental decision, the commission went even further. While affirming that it lacked jurisdiction over Aaronson because of the separation of powers doctrine, it also declared that ODC does not meet the code of conduct's definition of a state agency. That reasoning was based on the fact that the ODC was not created by an act of the General Assembly or a provision of the state constitution.

"As a result, the commission cannot conclude that Ms. Aaronson is a state employee because her employer, ODC, does not qualify as a state agency under our governing statute," the panel wrote.

Abbott and Aaronson did not return messages seeking comment on the dispute. Deborah Moreau, the commission's attorney, declined to comment while the case is pending.

In his complaint, Abbott alleged that Aaronson undertook the investigation of him, which included trying to obtain confidential attorney-client communications, to ingratiate herself with a member of the judiciary and to further her own ambitions for a judgeship. Abbott also complained that Aaronson communicated with Chief Justice Leo Strine Jr. to obtain confidential documentation from the Court on the Judiciary, which handles complaints regarding judicial officers, without notifying him.

"The cozy 'direct report' relationship between you and the chief justice could lead a reasonable person to believe that improper influence was utilized in order to gain such an extraordinary release of confidential papers," Abbott wrote in a letter to Aaronson.

"You have an initiated an investigation based on nothing but an unjustified request by your judiciary colleague to undertake a fishing expedition," he added, "... and you have attempted to abuse your powers by seeking documents that are clearly privileged in furtherance of that wild goose chase."

In response to a request from comment from Strine, a spokesman for the Administrative Office of the Courts said it would be inappropriate for the chief justice to comment on a pending matter.

Aaronson's investigation was prompted by a referral of Abbott to the ODC by a Chancery Court judge who presided over a long-running dispute between a homeowners association and a resident who refused to trim his trees and bushes.

After finding that the homeowner was in breach of a consent order regarding the foliage trimming, the judge directed the lawyers to work together toward a resolution. Abbott later informed the court that further proceedings were not necessary, because the homeowner had transferred title of the property to his wife.

The homeowners association argued that the property transfer, done at Abbott's advice, was a sham to evade a court order. The judge found Abott's client in contempt and told Abbott at a hearing that he had found "contemptuous behavior" on Abbott's part, but the judge did not issue a formal order declaring Abbott in contempt.

  • Delmarvawide NewsDelmarvawide NewsMore>>

  • Rehoboth Considers Potential Parking Solutions

    Rehoboth Considers Potential Parking Solutions

    Saturday, September 22 2018 3:11 AM EDT2018-09-22 07:11:01 GMT
    Saturday, September 22 2018 3:16 AM EDT2018-09-22 07:16:27 GMT
    Downtown Rehoboth Beach (Photo: WBOC)Downtown Rehoboth Beach (Photo: WBOC)
    Downtown Rehoboth Beach (Photo: WBOC)Downtown Rehoboth Beach (Photo: WBOC)
    Some in Rehoboth Beach say they're fed up with searching for parking in prime locations--like along Rehoboth Avenue. Today the city's parking advisory committee presented those solutions to the Board of Commissioners.More
    Some in Rehoboth Beach say they're fed up with searching for parking in prime locations--like along Rehoboth Avenue. Today the city's parking advisory committee presented those solutions to the Board of Commissioners. More
  • Investigation Finds Maryland Culpable in Death of Player

    Investigation Finds Maryland Culpable in Death of Player

    Saturday, September 22 2018 12:08 AM EDT2018-09-22 04:08:32 GMT
    Saturday, September 22 2018 12:08 AM EDT2018-09-22 04:08:32 GMT
    An independent investigation into the death of University of Maryland football player Jordan McNair has determined that trainers on the scene did not follow proper procedures after he collapsed on the field.More
    An independent investigation into the death of University of Maryland football player Jordan McNair has determined that trainers on the scene did not follow proper procedures after he collapsed on the field.More
  • Dorchester County Volunteers Gear Up for Ironman Maryland

    Dorchester County Volunteers Gear Up for Ironman Maryland

    Friday, September 21 2018 9:39 PM EDT2018-09-22 01:39:17 GMT
    Friday, September 21 2018 9:39 PM EDT2018-09-22 01:39:17 GMT
    Dorchester County is gearing up for Ironman Maryland. The event is set to kick off at Great Marsh Park next weekend.More
    Dorchester County is gearing up for Ironman Maryland. The event is set to kick off at Great Marsh Park next weekend.More
  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Kent County Man Shot While in His Yard

    Kent County Man Shot While in His Yard

    Friday, September 21 2018 6:20 PM EDT2018-09-21 22:20:00 GMT
    Friday, September 21 2018 6:23 PM EDT2018-09-21 22:23:48 GMT
    Credit: WBOCCredit: WBOC
    Credit: WBOCCredit: WBOC
    Delaware State Police are investigating a incident that occurred on September 20, where a man from Magnolia, Delaware was shot while trying to bring his dog inside.More
    Delaware State Police are investigating a incident that occurred on September 20, where a man from Magnolia, Delaware was shot while trying to bring his dog inside. More
  • Search For Suspects Domino's Pizza Burglary In Dover

    Search For Suspects Domino's Pizza Burglary In Dover

    Friday, September 21 2018 4:40 PM EDT2018-09-21 20:40:48 GMT
    Friday, September 21 2018 4:40 PM EDT2018-09-21 20:40:48 GMT
    Dover police is investigating the burglary of a Domino's Pizza early Friday morning.More
    Dover police is investigating the burglary of a Domino's Pizza early Friday morning.More
  • Rehoboth Considers Potential Parking Solutions

    Rehoboth Considers Potential Parking Solutions

    Saturday, September 22 2018 3:11 AM EDT2018-09-22 07:11:01 GMT
    Saturday, September 22 2018 3:16 AM EDT2018-09-22 07:16:27 GMT
    Downtown Rehoboth Beach (Photo: WBOC)Downtown Rehoboth Beach (Photo: WBOC)
    Downtown Rehoboth Beach (Photo: WBOC)Downtown Rehoboth Beach (Photo: WBOC)
    Some in Rehoboth Beach say they're fed up with searching for parking in prime locations--like along Rehoboth Avenue. Today the city's parking advisory committee presented those solutions to the Board of Commissioners.More
    Some in Rehoboth Beach say they're fed up with searching for parking in prime locations--like along Rehoboth Avenue. Today the city's parking advisory committee presented those solutions to the Board of Commissioners. More
  • Most Popular VideosMost Popular VideosMore>>

  • Sussex County Recovering Addict Reflects

    Sussex County Recovering Addict Reflects

    The Sussex County Health Coalition recently jumped on the purple band wagon to raise awareness for substance abuse. 

    In light of that campaign on local man, Bruce Ricketts, is speaking out about his journey through addiction in hopes of it becoming another person's inspiration. 

    Bruce lives with 11 other people in an Oxford house that all share similar struggles. The goal in the house is to give recovering addicts a safe place to rebuild their lives.

    More

    The Sussex County Health Coalition recently jumped on the purple band wagon to raise awareness for substance abuse. 

    In light of that campaign on local man, Bruce Ricketts, is speaking out about his journey through addiction in hopes of it becoming another person's inspiration. 

    Bruce lives with 11 other people in an Oxford house that all share similar struggles. The goal in the house is to give recovering addicts a safe place to rebuild their lives.

    More
  • Whale Skull Recovered from Pickering Beach in Kent County

    Whale Skull Recovered from Pickering Beach in Kent County

    The skull of a deceased juvenile whale that washed up along the Kent County coast last year was recovered on Friday at Pickering Beach by staffers with the Delaware Museum of Natural History.

    The whale initially turned up at Port Mahon but was moved to Pickering Beach by the State of Delaware to naturally decompose into the bones that remain on the beach.

    More

    The skull of a deceased juvenile whale that washed up along the Kent County coast last year was recovered on Friday at Pickering Beach by staffers with the Delaware Museum of Natural History.

    The whale initially turned up at Port Mahon but was moved to Pickering Beach by the State of Delaware to naturally decompose into the bones that remain on the beach.

    More
  • Rehoboth Considers Potential Parking Solutions

    Rehoboth Considers Potential Parking Solutions

    Some in Rehoboth Beach say they're fed up with searching for parking in prime locations--like along Rehoboth Avenue.

    Now--the city is exploring options to provide solutions to the problem. Today the city's parking advisory committee presented those solutions to the Board of Commissioners.  

    Among some of the explored topics were extending the meter season in the city, as well as hiking up the price of metered parking in popular areas.

    More

    Some in Rehoboth Beach say they're fed up with searching for parking in prime locations--like along Rehoboth Avenue.

    Now--the city is exploring options to provide solutions to the problem. Today the city's parking advisory committee presented those solutions to the Board of Commissioners.  

    Among some of the explored topics were extending the meter season in the city, as well as hiking up the price of metered parking in popular areas.

    More
Powered by Frankly

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 WBOC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices