Sniper Who Terrorized Nation's Capital Seeks Lower Sentence - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -

Sniper Who Terrorized Nation's Capital Seeks Lower Sentence

Posted: Jan 23, 2018 3:05 PM Updated:
In this Oct. 20, 2003, file photo, Lee Boyd Malvo listens to court proceedings during the trial of fellow sniper suspect John Allen Muhammad in Virginia Beach, Va. (Photo: AP) In this Oct. 20, 2003, file photo, Lee Boyd Malvo listens to court proceedings during the trial of fellow sniper suspect John Allen Muhammad in Virginia Beach, Va. (Photo: AP)

RICHMOND, Va. (AP)- A sniper who randomly killed 10 people and terrorized the Washington, D.C., region more than 15 years ago is entitled to a new hearing to ask for a lighter sentence, his lawyer argued Tuesday to a federal appeals court.

Lee Boyd Malvo was 17 when he and his mentor, John Allen Muhammad, then 41, shot people in Virginia, Maryland and Washington as they pumped gas, loaded packages into their cars and went about their everyday business during a three-week period in 2002.

Muhammad was sentenced to death and was executed in Virginia in 2009.

A jury convicted Malvo of capital murder for killing FBI analyst Linda Franklin, who was shot in the head outside a Home Depot store, but spared him the death penalty. Malvo later struck plea deals in other cases in Virginia and Maryland. He ultimately received four life sentences in Virginia and six in Maryland.

Malvo's lawyer Craig Cooley on Tuesday urged the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to uphold a ruling by a federal judge who last year ordered new sentencing hearings in Virginia under a U.S. Supreme Court ruling that found mandatory life-without-parole sentences for juveniles unconstitutional. A 2016 Supreme Court ruling made the decision retroactive, extending it to people like Malvo who were already sentenced before the court found such punishments unconstitutional.

Cooley said the judge who presided at Malvo's trial gave the jury only two choices in recommending a sentence for Malvo - life in prison without the possibility of parole or the death penalty - with no option for a lesser sentence.

Jurors, Cooley said, "opted to go as low as they could under the structure they were given on that date." He said the jury's unanimous decision to give him life instead of the death penalty indicates "they may have gone lower if they knew they could have."

But Deputy Solicitor General Matthew McGuire said the trial judge had discretion to reduce the jury's recommendation, but did not do so. He said the Supreme Court ruling does not apply to states that don't have mandatory life-without-parole sentences.

The three-judge panel questioned Cooley extensively about Malvo's plea deal with prosecutors in which he agreed to plead guilty and receive a sentence of life in exchange for prosecutors dropping some charges and removing the death penalty as a possible sentence.

"How do you get around the plea agreement - the finality of plea agreements?" Judge Paul Niemeyer asked Cooley.

Cooley said Malvo agreed to "what is now an illegal sentence, an unconstitutional sentence."

After the hearing, Cooley told reporters that Malvo is simply asking for the opportunity to argue for a new sentence. He noted that Malvo still faces life sentences in Maryland, where a judge ruled last year that he will not get new sentencing hearings.

"In the end, it doesn't mean that he's walking out of prison," Cooley said.

The court did not indicate when it will rule.

Other former teen offenders still are awaiting a chance at resentencing in states and counties that have been slow to address the court ruling, an earlier Associated Press investigation found. In Michigan, for example, prosecutors are seeking new no-parole sentences for nearly two-thirds of 363 juvenile lifers. Those cases are on hold until the Michigan Supreme Court determines whether judges or juries should decide the fate of those inmates. The court heard arguments in October.

Some courts are applying the 2016 ruling to those whose life-without-parole sentences weren't mandatory, like Malvo's, or were negotiated as part of a plea deal.

  • Delmarvawide NewsDelmarvawide NewsMore>>

  • Woman Identified as Suspect in Dover Business Burglary

    Woman Identified as Suspect in Dover Business Burglary

    Tuesday, October 23 2018 10:24 AM EDT2018-10-23 14:24:51 GMT
    Tuesday, October 23 2018 10:24 AM EDT2018-10-23 14:24:51 GMT
    DOVER, Del. - Police are looking for a woman suspected in a burglary at the Spence's Bazaar. The incident happened October 14 around 5:30 am. According to police, someone entered the business through a door and stole several items from vendor booths. The More
    DOVER, Del. - Police are looking for a woman suspected in a burglary at the Spence's Bazaar. The incident happened October 14 around 5:30 am. According to police, someone entered the business through a door and stole several items from vendor booths. The More
  • Conflict Over Ocean View Marina

    Conflict Over Ocean View Marina

    Tuesday, October 23 2018 9:38 AM EDT2018-10-23 13:38:16 GMT
    Tuesday, October 23 2018 10:00 AM EDT2018-10-23 14:00:06 GMT
    OCEAN VIEW, Del.- Intersecting properties in Ocean View are at the center of a restaurant proposal and the future of the area's trail head and local business. Tom Fowler owns the Ocean View Marina on Elliott Avenue. Part of the marina is on his land, butMore
    OCEAN VIEW, Del.- Intersecting properties in Ocean View are at the center of a restaurant proposal and the future of the area's trail head and local business. Tom Fowler owns the Ocean View Marina on Elliott Avenue. Part of the marina is on his land, but More
  • Delaware House Candidate Says She Removed Rival's Pamphlet

    Delaware House Candidate Says She Removed Rival's Pamphlet

    Tuesday, October 23 2018 9:09 AM EDT2018-10-23 13:09:31 GMT
    Tuesday, October 23 2018 9:09 AM EDT2018-10-23 13:09:31 GMT
    This photo taken from a video posted on Facebook by Middletown's Randy Smith on Sunday allegedly shows Democratic state House candidate Monique Johns removing her political rival's campaign pamphlet and replacing it with her own. (Photo: Randy Smith)This photo taken from a video posted on Facebook by Middletown's Randy Smith on Sunday allegedly shows Democratic state House candidate Monique Johns removing her political rival's campaign pamphlet and replacing it with her own. (Photo: Randy Smith)
    This photo taken from a video posted on Facebook by Middletown's Randy Smith on Sunday allegedly shows Democratic state House candidate Monique Johns removing her political rival's campaign pamphlet and replacing it with her own. (Photo: Randy Smith)This photo taken from a video posted on Facebook by Middletown's Randy Smith on Sunday allegedly shows Democratic state House candidate Monique Johns removing her political rival's campaign pamphlet and replacing it with her own. (Photo: Randy Smith)
    A Delaware state house candidate has acknowledged removing her opponent's campaign literature from the front door of a home.More
    A Delaware state house candidate has acknowledged removing her opponent's campaign literature from the front door of a home.           More
  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Some Sussex County Communities Set Age Limit for Trick-Or-Treaters

    Some Sussex County Communities Set Age Limit for Trick-Or-Treaters

    Monday, October 22 2018 4:35 PM EDT2018-10-22 20:35:08 GMT
    Tuesday, October 23 2018 7:29 AM EDT2018-10-23 11:29:14 GMT
    Halloween is nearly a week away and parents and kids are gearing up for the big day. But some town and city officials throughout Sussex County, Delaware are encouraging that only kids under 12 participate in trick-or-treating to increase safety.More
    Halloween is nearly a week away and parents and kids are gearing up for the big day. But some town and city officials throughout Sussex County, Delaware are encouraging that only kids under 12 participate in trick-or-treating to increase safety.More
  • Defense Says Witness Played Major Role in Delaware Prison Riot

    Defense Says Witness Played Major Role in Delaware Prison Riot

    Monday, October 22 2018 6:12 PM EDT2018-10-22 22:12:35 GMT
    Tuesday, October 23 2018 7:32 AM EDT2018-10-23 11:32:36 GMT
    Aerial view of the James T. Vaughn Correctional Center in Smyrna. (Photo: WBOC Chopper 16)Aerial view of the James T. Vaughn Correctional Center in Smyrna. (Photo: WBOC Chopper 16)
    Aerial view of the James T. Vaughn Correctional Center in Smyrna. (Photo: WBOC Chopper 16)Aerial view of the James T. Vaughn Correctional Center in Smyrna. (Photo: WBOC Chopper 16)
    The star prosecution witness in the trial of four Delaware inmates charged with murder, kidnapping and other crimes after a fatal prison riot played a key role in the disturbance and...More
    The star prosecution witness in the trial of four Delaware inmates charged with murder, kidnapping and other crimes after a fatal prison riot played a key role in the disturbance and...More
  • Clayton Police Chief Pleads Guilty to First Offense DUI, Resigns

    Clayton Police Chief Avoids Jail Time After DUI Arrest

    Monday, October 22 2018 4:18 PM EDT2018-10-22 20:18:14 GMT
    Tuesday, October 23 2018 8:45 AM EDT2018-10-23 12:45:33 GMT
    A Kent County, Delaware police chief set to go to trial on a drunken driving charge has pleaded guilty and resigned his post.More
    A Kent County, Delaware police chief set to go to trial on a drunken driving charge has pleaded guilty and resigned his post.More
  • Most Popular VideosMost Popular VideosMore>>

  • Weather Impacts Local Farmers

    Weather Impacts Local Farmers

    We've experienced some wet weather this season and while you may think that's good for farm land...it's not. Many farmers say the rain has actually been too much for their crops.

    More

    We've experienced some wet weather this season and while you may think that's good for farm land...it's not. Many farmers say the rain has actually been too much for their crops.

    More
  • Trial Begins for Inmates in Deadly Delaware Prison Riot

    Trial Begins for Inmates in Deadly Delaware Prison Riot

    The star prosecution witness in the trial of four Delaware inmates charged with murder, kidnapping and other crimes following a deadly prison riot last year played a key role in the disturbance and likely ordered the killing of a prison guard, a defense attorney claimed during opening statements Monday.

    More

    The star prosecution witness in the trial of four Delaware inmates charged with murder, kidnapping and other crimes following a deadly prison riot last year played a key role in the disturbance and likely ordered the killing of a prison guard, a defense attorney claimed during opening statements Monday.

    More
  • Some Sussex County Communities Set Age Limit for Trick-Or-Treaters

    Some Sussex County Communities Set Age Limit for Trick-Or-Treaters

    Halloween is nearly a week away and parents and kids are gearing up for the big day. But town and city officials throughout Sussex County are encouraging that only kids under 12 participate in trick-or-treating to increase safety among children.  

    More

    Halloween is nearly a week away and parents and kids are gearing up for the big day. But town and city officials throughout Sussex County are encouraging that only kids under 12 participate in trick-or-treating to increase safety among children.  

    More
Powered by Frankly

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 WBOC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices