Killer Returned to Prison After Release Eyes Sentence Change - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -

Killer Returned to Prison After Release Eyes Sentence Change

Posted: Feb 13, 2018 8:15 PM Updated:

By RANDALL CHASE
Associated Press

DOVER, Del. (AP) - A Delaware judge is weighing whether to grant a sentence reduction for a killer who was ordered back to prison after Delaware's Supreme Court reversed a judge's ruling that had freed her.

Following a hearing Tuesday, the judge gave attorneys two weeks to submit letters on whether they think he has any discretion to deny a sentence reduction for Catherine Culp if he finds that the request was made with good cause, and that she does not present a risk to the public.

The application for a sentence reduction was submitted after both the Department of Correction and Board of Parole determined that Culp's model behavior as an inmate justified her early release.

Culp, 58, was initially sentenced to life in prison for the 1998 shooting death of her boyfriend, Lee Hicks. Following a retrial, she was convicted of second-degree murder and sentenced in 2001 to 25 years in prison. Her current release date, with good time credit, is March 2019.

"The lady that sits before the court today is not the lady who committed this crime," defense attorney William Deely told Superior Court Judge Noel Primos. ".... She's an entirely different person."

Deputy attorney general Dennis Kelleher argued that Culp's original sentence was appropriate and should stand. He also noted that Culp has maintained that Hicks' death was an accident while the evidence suggests otherwise, and that she has given conflicting and contradictory statements about what happened.

"It was a completely unprovoked attack that resulted in a man's death," Kelleher said.

Culp, who appeared in court in a purple jumpsuit and leg shackles, did not speak.

Culp was freed on probation for about nine months in 2016 after Superior Court Judge Robert Young, who attended Tuesday's hearing, concluded that her model conduct and extensive rehabilitation efforts met the standard under court rules for "extraordinary circumstances" justifying a sentence modification. The ruling resulted in her being released on probation.

Delaware's Supreme Court reversed Young's ruling, saying court rules barred him from considering a second motion for sentence reduction by Culp after a similar motion had been denied in 2003. The justices also noted that participation in educational and rehabilitative programs does not, in and of itself, constitute "extraordinary circumstances."

The Supreme Court also noted in 2016 that, unlike the pending motion, the Department of Correction had not filed an application on Culp's behalf with the Board of Parole. Under Delaware's criminal code, a judge can modify a sentence based on an application by the DOC "for good cause shown which certifies that the release of the defendant shall not constitute a substantial risk to the community or the defendant's own self."

Deely noted that the DOC's recommendation for Culp's sentence reduction was unanimous.

"Ms. Culp has done more than any other client I've ever had, or ever seen, while she was incarcerated," he said.

In reducing Culp's sentence in 2016, Young cited a host of her achievements behind bars, including earning an associate's degree, teaching classes, tutoring inmates and training other tutors. He also noted that Culp had earned a computer operator certificate and had completed courses in Spanish, culinary arts, women's health, public speaking, dancing and floral design.

Kelleher, the prosecutor, said Tuesday that while Culp's achievements in prison were "admirable" they did not necessarily warrant a sentence reduction.

"That's what you're supposed to do in prison," he said.

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Police Investigating Pocomoke American Legion Shooting

    Police Investigating Pocomoke American Legion Shooting

    Feb 18, 2018 3:03 PM2018-02-18 20:03:00 GMT
    Sunday, February 18 2018 3:03 PM EST2018-02-18 20:03:08 GMT
    Pocomoke Police are investigating a shooting that happened at the American Legion early Sunday morning.More
    Pocomoke Police are investigating a shooting that happened at the American Legion early Sunday morning. More
  • Delaware State Auditor Does Not Seek Re-election

    Delaware State Auditor Does Not Seek Re-election

    Feb 17, 2018 11:41 PM2018-02-18 04:41:00 GMT
    Saturday, February 17 2018 11:41 PM EST2018-02-18 04:41:58 GMT
    DOVER, De.- Delaware state auditor, Tom Wagner, has announced he will not seek re-election this year. Wagner was appointed to the position in 1989 and was elected to his seventh term in 2014. He’s one of two Republicans elected to statewide office. More
    DOVER, De.- Delaware state auditor, Tom Wagner, has announced he will not seek re-election this year. Wagner was appointed to the position in 1989 and was elected to his seventh term in 2014. He’s one of two Republicans elected to statewide office. More
  • Traffic Stop Leads to Police Pursuit; Weapons and Drugs Seized

    Traffic Stop Leads to Police Pursuit; Weapons and Drugs Seized

    Feb 17, 2018 3:27 PM2018-02-17 20:27:00 GMT
    Saturday, February 17 2018 3:32 PM EST2018-02-17 20:32:23 GMT
    Courtesy of the Georgetown Police Department Courtesy of the Georgetown Police Department
    The Georgetown Police Department said they arrested a Brooklyn, NY, man early Friday morning after he lead them on a pursuit and had various drugs and guns in his car.More
    The Georgetown Police Department said they arrested a Brooklyn, NY, man early Friday morning after he lead them on a pursuit and had various drugs and guns in his car. More
Powered by Frankly

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 WBOC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices