Supreme Court Takes Up 2nd Major Partisan Redistricting Case - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -

Supreme Court Takes Up 2nd Major Partisan Redistricting Case

Posted: Mar 26, 2018 2:53 AM Updated:

WASHINGTON (AP) - The Supreme Court has already heard a major case about political line-drawing that has the potential to reshape American politics. Now, before even deciding that one, the court is taking up another similar case.

The arguments justices will hear Wednesday in the second case, a Republican challenge to a Democratic-leaning congressional district in Maryland, could offer fresh clues to what they are thinking about partisan gerrymandering, an increasingly hot topic before courts.

Decisions in the Maryland case and the earlier one from Wisconsin are expected by late June.

The arguments come nearly six months after the court heard a dispute over Wisconsin legislative districts that Democrats claim were drawn to maximize Republican control in a state that is closely divided between the parties.

The Supreme Court has never thrown out electoral districts on partisan grounds and it's not clear the justices will do so now. But supporters of limits on partisanship in redistricting are encouraged that the justices are considering two cases.

"In taking these two cases, the Supreme Court wants to say something about partisan gerrymandering. It's clear the Supreme Court is not walking away from the issue," said Michael Li, senior counsel at the New York University law school's Brennan Center for Justice.

The justices' involvement in partisan redistricting reflects a period of unusual activity in the courts on this topic. Over the past 16 months, courts struck down political districting plans drawn by Republicans in North Carolina, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin. Federal judges threw out a state legislative map in Wisconsin and a congressional plan in North Carolina. In Pennsylvania, the state Supreme Court invalidated the state's congressional districts and replaced them with a court-drawn plan.

When the Supreme Court heard Wisconsin's appeal, the court appeared to be split along familiar lines. Four liberal justices seemed inclined to strike down the legislative map and four conservatives appeared more favorable to it. That left Justice Anthony Kennedy seemingly in control of the outcome.

A relatively quick resolution of the case also appeared likely, based on the way the court handled the case. A lower court had earlier struck down the districts and ordered new ones drawn. The justices blocked the drawing of a new map last summer, but set the case for arguments in the first week of its new term in October.

Then in December, the court said it would hear the case about Maryland's 6th congressional district, but provided no further explanation about why it was adding a second redistricting case.

Democrats who controlled redistricting in Maryland in 2011 made a conscious decision to try to increase the party's control of congressional districts from 6-2 to 7-1, said Michael Kimberly, the lawyer representing the Republican challengers.

They took a district that had been centered in rural, Republican-leaning northwestern Maryland, where a longtime Republican incumbent won by 28 percentage points in 2010 and turned it into a district that took in some Democratic Washington, D.C., suburbs and elected a Democrat who won by 21 percentage points in 2012.

The change violated the First Amendment rights of the Republican voters, Kimberly said.

Maryland Attorney General Brian Frosh, a Democrat, said in defending the district that it is competitive for both parties and has elected a moderate Democrat. In 2014, a friendlier year for Republican candidates, Democratic Rep. John Delaney's victory margin dropped to less than 2 points, though it rose again in 2016.

In some ways, the Wisconsin and Maryland cases complement each other. In Wisconsin, the justices have a broad theory about partisan line-drawing. The lower court that ruled for the Democratic challengers concluded that the districting plans were drawn to discriminate against Democrats, the Republicans' advantage would endure even in the face of a strong Democratic showing at the polls and the plans could not be explained by other, non-partisan reasons.

In Maryland, the single-district approach looks a lot like the way civil rights groups try to prove that race played too large a role in the drawing of districts. It would be both a more limited approach than the Wisconsin case, but also feel more familiar to justices who have decided many claims of racial bias in redistricting.

With two cases before them, the justices now have one in which each party is complaining about the other.

That could be significant based on Chief Justice John Roberts' stated distaste for putting the court's credibility at stake in politically charged cases.

"We'll have to decide in every case whether the Democrats win or the Republicans win," Roberts said in the Wisconsin arguments.

Another possibility is that the justices could already have decided that there's a procedural problem in the Wisconsin case, limiting their ability to address the merits of the Democratic voters' claim.

However the court views the two cases, it seems increasingly likely that a decision striking down districts won't result in any changes this year. The court frowns on making these sorts of changes so close to an election. The deadline to get on the primary ballot in Wisconsin is June 1. Maryland's deadline was last month.

The court also has blocked new congressional districts in North Carolina.

Only in Pennsylvania, where the state Supreme Court invoked the state constitution to strike down the congressional map, has a new map been put in place. The Supreme Court refused an emergency request from Pennsylvania Republicans to block it.

  • Delmarvawide NewsDelmarvawide NewsMore>>

  • Delaware Eyes Ban on Single-Use Plastic Bags

    Delaware Eyes Ban on Single-Use Plastic Bags

    Thursday, April 18 2019 6:34 PM EDT2019-04-18 22:34:44 GMT
    Thursday, April 18 2019 6:45 PM EDT2019-04-18 22:45:28 GMT
    (Photo: WBOC)(Photo: WBOC)
    (Photo: WBOC)(Photo: WBOC)
    DOVER, Del. --- The First State may become the next state to ban single-use plastic bags at businesses like grocery stores. House Bill 130 expands the state's recycling program but stores subject to the program will be barred from providing single-use plaMore
    DOVER, Del. --- The First State may become the next state to ban single-use plastic bags at businesses like grocery stores. House Bill 130 expands the state's recycling program but stores subject to the program will be barred from providing single-use plaMore
  • Tree Companies Rally For Families Impacted By Tornado

    Tree Companies Rally For Families Impacted By Tornado

    Thursday, April 18 2019 6:59 PM EDT2019-04-18 22:59:06 GMT
    Thursday, April 18 2019 6:59 PM EDT2019-04-18 22:59:30 GMT
    Workers spent all day removing big trees that destroyed multiple homes in Laurel after Monday's tornado.More
    Workers spent all day removing big trees that destroyed multiple homes in Laurel after Monday's tornado. More
  • Blood Bank of Delmarva In Need of Donors

    Blood Bank of Delmarva In Need of Donors

    Thursday, April 18 2019 6:55 PM EDT2019-04-18 22:55:09 GMT
    Thursday, April 18 2019 6:55 PM EDT2019-04-18 22:55:09 GMT
    Blood Bank of Delmarva Helping Texas Blood Banks (WBOC PHOTO)Blood Bank of Delmarva Helping Texas Blood Banks (WBOC PHOTO)
    Blood Bank of Delmarva Helping Texas Blood Banks (WBOC PHOTO)Blood Bank of Delmarva Helping Texas Blood Banks (WBOC PHOTO)
    A decline in blood donors has lowered blood bank supplies to dangerous levels on Delmarva.More
    A decline in blood donors has lowered blood bank supplies to dangerous levels on Delmarva.More
  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Fugitive Warrant Effort Leads to 107 Arrests in Wicomico, Dorchester Counties

    Fugitive Warrant Effort Leads to 107 Arrests in Wicomico, Dorchester Counties

    Thursday, April 18 2019 8:54 AM EDT2019-04-18 12:54:48 GMT
    Thursday, April 18 2019 9:00 AM EDT2019-04-18 13:00:47 GMT
    Maryland State Police, in partnership with allied law enforcement agencies in Wicomico and Dorchester counties, arrested more than 100 people as part of a continued effort to reduce the amount of active fugitive warrants in the lower Eastern Shore.More
    Maryland State Police, in partnership with allied law enforcement agencies in Wicomico and Dorchester counties, arrested more than 100 people as part of a continued effort to reduce the amount of active fugitive warrants in the lower Eastern Shore.More
  • Fight Outside Dover Night Club Sends Three to the Hospital

    Fight Outside Dover Night Club Sends Three to the Hospital

    Wednesday, April 17 2019 8:57 PM EDT2019-04-18 00:57:37 GMT
    Wednesday, April 17 2019 8:57 PM EDT2019-04-18 00:57:37 GMT
    Dover Police said three people are recovering from stab-like wounds after a fight broke out near a night club early Wednesday morning.More
    Dover Police said three people are recovering from stab-like wounds after a fight broke out near a night club early Wednesday morning. More
  • State Police Divers Search Silver Lake in Dover

    State Police Divers Search Silver Lake in Dover

    Wednesday, April 17 2019 2:50 PM EDT2019-04-17 18:50:29 GMT
    Wednesday, April 17 2019 2:57 PM EDT2019-04-17 18:57:44 GMT
    DOVER, Del. --- State police divers on Wednesday searched a section of Silver Lake in Dover in an effort to assist an investigation by Dover law enforcement, according to city police. Cpl. Mark Hoffman, a Dover police spokesman, would not comment on whatMore
    DOVER, Del. --- State police divers on Wednesday searched a section of Silver Lake in Dover in an effort to assist an investigation by Dover law enforcement, according to city police. Cpl. Mark Hoffman, a Dover police spokesman, would not comment on what More
  • Most Popular VideosMost Popular VideosMore>>

  • WBOC Morning Weather: April 18, 2019

    WBOC Morning Weather: April 18, 2019

  • Woman Walking the World Reaches Sussex County

    Woman Walking the World Reaches Sussex County

    A Virginia Beach woman spent the last five years walking around the world, and this week, she passed through Delaware. Joined by her mother for the East Coast portion of her journey, Angela Maxwell set off from the Lincoln Memorial last week and made it to Milton Wednesday afternoon. Maxwell says her journey serves a larger purpose though. She says she's walking to help boys and girls saved from sex trafficking.

    More

    A Virginia Beach woman spent the last five years walking around the world, and this week, she passed through Delaware. Joined by her mother for the East Coast portion of her journey, Angela Maxwell set off from the Lincoln Memorial last week and made it to Milton Wednesday afternoon. Maxwell says her journey serves a larger purpose though. She says she's walking to help boys and girls saved from sex trafficking.

    More
  • Space Station Shipment Launch A Success From Wallops Island

    Space Station Shipment Launch A Success From Wallops Island

    The Antares rocket launch at Wallops Island was a success Wednesday afternoon.

    Northrop Grumman's Antares rocket blasted off Wednesday from Wallops Island. The company's Cygnus capsule should arrive at the International Space Station Friday, just in time for Easter.
     

    More

    The Antares rocket launch at Wallops Island was a success Wednesday afternoon.

    Northrop Grumman's Antares rocket blasted off Wednesday from Wallops Island. The company's Cygnus capsule should arrive at the International Space Station Friday, just in time for Easter.
     

    More
Powered by Frankly

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2019 WBOC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices