Court Upholds Conspiracy Conviction in Fatal Bathroom Attack - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -

Court Upholds Conspiracy Conviction in Fatal Bathroom Attack

Posted: Apr 11, 2018 9:03 PM Updated:

By RANDALL CHASE
Associated Press

DOVER, Del. (AP) - Delaware's Supreme Court has upheld the conspiracy conviction of a teenage girl in a school bathroom attack that left a 16-year-old classmate dead.

In an order dated Tuesday, the court rejected the girl's arguments that there was insufficient evidence to convict her in the April 2016 attack that left Amy Joyner-Francis dead.

The ruling came after the Supreme Court last month overturned a codefendant's conviction for criminally negligent homicide for her role in the attack, while upholding her conspiracy conviction. In that ruling, the Supreme Court said no reasonable fact-finder could have found that the girl acted with criminal negligence. Even if she did, the justices said, it would be unjust to blame her for Joyner-Francis' death given how unforeseeable it was that the fight would lead to a young teen dying of cardiac arrest.

An autopsy found that Joyner-Francis, who had a rare, undetected, heart condition, died of sudden cardiac death, aggravated by physical and emotional stress from the fight at Howard High School of Technology in Wilmington.

Cellphone video of the attack, which gained national attention, shows Joyner-Francis struggling to fight back and escape as she is repeatedly hit and kicked in the head while her assailant holds on to her hair.

Three girls were charged in the incident. Two were convicted, while the third was acquitted on a conspiracy charge. The Associated Press has not published their names because they were tried as juveniles. The Supreme Court in its rulings has referred to the defendants using pseudonyms.

The defendant, identified in Tuesday's ruling under the pseudonym Zachary Schaffer, argued that Joyner-Francis was a "mutual combatant" in a fight between two willing parties, and that she thus could not be convicted of conspiracy to commit assault.

"Even if Schaffer's theory has merit - a question on which we express no opinion - it had little evidentiary support," Justice Gary Traynor wrote on behalf of a three-judge panel.

The girl also claimed that a Family Court judge who presided over a non-jury trial erred in allowing prosecutors to introduce two Snapchat videos as evidence without adequate authentication.

One of the videos, posted the day before the attack, shows Joyner-Francis talking to her assailant in the bathroom, purportedly to try to defuse the situation. The posting notes that the girl later convicted of homicide was "bouta fight her," followed by several emojis indicating that a person was laughing so hard she was crying.

The other video bore a caption that read, "We gonna get her. She's scared."

Two witnesses testified that they had seen one or both videos posted to Schaffer's account.

Schaffer pointed out that the witnesses could not remember exactly when they watched the videos. She also suggested that the videos could have been manipulated after they had been posted to her account to add the captions.

Pointing to the testimony of Schaffer's two classmates, the justices rejected those arguments, saying the Family Court did not err in allowing the videos into evidence.

The Supreme Court also rejected arguments that Schaffer's rights were violated because investigators were unable to recover an iPad issued by the school to Francis. Schaffer suggested the device may have contained information indicating that Joyner-Francis was willing to fight.

While detectives were unable to find the iPad, the justices noted that evidence the state was able to obtain of conversations Joyner-Francis had with a friend the day before the attack gave no indication that she had been willing to fight.

Prosecutors traced the conflict to an online group chat the day before the attack, when Joyner-Francis had offered advice to a friend about a problem involving a boy, telling her friend to "just be careful." Joyner-Francis warned that someone might "switch up," or betray another person. A police detective said the assailant thought Joyner-Francis was talking about her as the possible traitor.

The family of Joyner-Francis filed a lawsuit last week against the school district and the two girls convicted in the case.

  • Delmarvawide NewsDelmarvawide NewsMore>>

  • Delaware Revenue Estimate Rises Again as Budget Votes Near

    Delaware Revenue Estimate Rises Again as Budget Votes Near

    Jun 18, 2018 3:19 PM2018-06-18 19:19:00 GMT
    Monday, June 18 2018 3:19 PM EDT2018-06-18 19:19:31 GMT
    A state panel has added more than $46 million to this year's government revenue estimate as lawmakers prepare to vote on budget bills for the upcoming fiscal year.More
    A state panel has added more than $46 million to this year's government revenue estimate as lawmakers prepare to vote on budget bills for the upcoming fiscal year.           More
  • Salisbury University's Female-only Camp Gets Underway

    Salisbury University's Female Only Camp Gets Underway

    Jun 18, 2018 2:53 PM2018-06-18 18:53:00 GMT
    Monday, June 18 2018 3:10 PM EDT2018-06-18 19:10:52 GMT
    Salisbury University's Girls Innovation Academy started today by touring the school's environmentally friendly efforts.Salisbury University's Girls Innovation Academy started today by touring the school's environmentally friendly efforts.
    Salisbury University's Girls Innovation Academy started today by touring the school's environmentally friendly efforts.Salisbury University's Girls Innovation Academy started today by touring the school's environmentally friendly efforts.
    For the second year in a row, Salisbury University is teaching young women that they can achieve anything they envision, even in traditionally male-dominated fields. The Girls Innovation Academy teaches its campers, "if you can see it, you can become it."More
    For the second year in a row, Salisbury University is teaching young women that they can achieve anything they envision, even in traditionally male-dominated fields. The Girls Innovation Academy teaches its campers, "if you can see it, you can become it."More
  • New Traffic Pattern Along Rt. 113 in Worcester County

    New Traffic Pattern Along Rt. 113 in Worcester County

    Jun 18, 2018 11:16 AM2018-06-18 15:16:00 GMT
    Monday, June 18 2018 1:13 PM EDT2018-06-18 17:13:39 GMT
    (Photo: WBOC)(Photo: WBOC)
    (Photo: WBOC)(Photo: WBOC)
    The Maryland State Highway Administration has shifted the traffic pattern along a section of Rt. 113 in Worcester County from Five Mile Branch to north of Langmaid Road.More
    The Maryland State Highway Administration has shifted the traffic pattern along a section of Rt. 113 in Worcester County from Five Mile Branch to north of Langmaid Road.More
  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Funeral Arrangements Announced for Ocean City's "Boardwalk Elvis"

    Funeral Arrangements Announced for Ocean City's "Boardwalk Elvis"

    Jun 18, 2018 6:47 AM2018-06-18 10:47:00 GMT
    Monday, June 18 2018 7:57 AM EDT2018-06-18 11:57:12 GMT
    Funeral and viewing arrangements have been announced for the man known to many as "Boardwalk Elvis."More
    Funeral and viewing arrangements have been announced for the man known to many as "Boardwalk Elvis."More
  • Fourth of July Fireworks on Delmarva 2018

    Fourth of July Fireworks on Delmarva 2018

    Jun 08, 2018 9:11 AM2018-06-08 13:11:00 GMT
    Monday, June 18 2018 8:20 AM EDT2018-06-18 12:20:01 GMT
    (MGN Online)(MGN Online)
    (MGN Online)(MGN Online)
    Looking for a place to watch the fireworks this Independence Day? Click on "more" for a list of dates, times and locations of Fourth of July events being held this year across Delmarva.More
    Looking for a place to watch the fireworks this Independence Day? Click on "more" for a list of dates, times and locations of Fourth of July events being held this year across Delmarva.
    More
  • Ferry Sunk for Delaware Artificial Reef

    Ferry Sunk For Delaware Artificial Reef

    Jun 16, 2018 5:24 PM2018-06-16 21:24:00 GMT
    Monday, June 18 2018 7:44 AM EDT2018-06-18 11:44:46 GMT
    Retired Lewes-to-Cape May ferry M/V Twin Capes under tow and en route to joining Delaware’s acclaimed artificial reef system. (Photo: DNREC)Retired Lewes-to-Cape May ferry M/V Twin Capes under tow and en route to joining Delaware’s acclaimed artificial reef system. (Photo: DNREC)
    Retired Lewes-to-Cape May ferry M/V Twin Capes under tow and en route to joining Delaware’s acclaimed artificial reef system. (Photo: DNREC)Retired Lewes-to-Cape May ferry M/V Twin Capes under tow and en route to joining Delaware’s acclaimed artificial reef system. (Photo: DNREC)
    A 320-foot-long ferry has been intentionally sunk to become part of an artificial reef off Delaware's coast.More
    A 320-foot-long ferry has been intentionally sunk to become part of an artificial reef off Delaware's coast. More
  • Most Popular VideosMost Popular VideosMore>>

  • Watch: Former Cape May Ferry Sunk for Use as Artificial Reef

    Watch: Former Cape May Ferry Sunk for Use as Artificial Reef

    On Friday, a former Cape May-Lewes ferry was sunk to become part of Delaware’s artificial reef system. The Twin Capes joined the Del-Jersey-Land reef’s submerged fleet that includes the ex-destroyer USS Arthur W. Radford, which went down in 2011 as the longest ship reefed on the East Coast, and the Zuni/Tamaroa, a Battle of Iwo Jima survivor turned US Coast Guard cutter that plied Atlantic waters for nearly 50 years.

    More

    On Friday, a former Cape May-Lewes ferry was sunk to become part of Delaware’s artificial reef system. The Twin Capes joined the Del-Jersey-Land reef’s submerged fleet that includes the ex-destroyer USS Arthur W. Radford, which went down in 2011 as the longest ship reefed on the East Coast, and the Zuni/Tamaroa, a Battle of Iwo Jima survivor turned US Coast Guard cutter that plied Atlantic waters for nearly 50 years.

    More
  • Woman Found Dead at Firefly Campground

    Woman Found Dead at Firefly Campground

    The Dover Police Department is investigating after a 20-year-old woman was found dead at the firefly campground. Police say around 6:30 a.m. officers were alerted to an unresponsive woman at Firefly Camping Lot 18. Police say the woman was found unconscious at her campsite and was treated by medical staff before she was transported to Bayhealth Kent General Hospital. There, authorities say she was pronounced dead at 6:55 a.m.

    More

    The Dover Police Department is investigating after a 20-year-old woman was found dead at the firefly campground. Police say around 6:30 a.m. officers were alerted to an unresponsive woman at Firefly Camping Lot 18. Police say the woman was found unconscious at her campsite and was treated by medical staff before she was transported to Bayhealth Kent General Hospital. There, authorities say she was pronounced dead at 6:55 a.m.

    More
  • Salisbury Fire Department Recovers Car in River

    Salisbury Fire Department Recovers Car in River

    The Salisbury Fire Department spent Sunday morning recovering a partially submerged car in the Wicomico River. According to the fire department, firefighters were dispatched to the river near Market Street Inn around 11:30 a.m. Once on scene, officials found a car in the river with a person inside. The fire department described the person in the car as "combative" and required police assistance to remove the person from the car.

    More

    The Salisbury Fire Department spent Sunday morning recovering a partially submerged car in the Wicomico River. According to the fire department, firefighters were dispatched to the river near Market Street Inn around 11:30 a.m. Once on scene, officials found a car in the river with a person inside. The fire department described the person in the car as "combative" and required police assistance to remove the person from the car.

    More
Powered by Frankly

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 WBOC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices