High Court Decision Extends Legal Battle Over Gerrymandering - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -

High Court Decision Extends Legal Battle Over Gerrymandering

Posted: Jun 19, 2018 3:39 AM Updated:

MADISON, Wis. (AP) - Democrats hoped a Wisconsin case would be the vehicle the U.S. Supreme Court would use to strike down highly partisan gerrymandering of electoral maps.

When those hopes fizzled Monday, attention turned to North Carolina. A case challenging that battleground state's congressional districts appears to offer stronger evidence of harm.

At issue is whether opponents can identify specific voters who say they have been hurt by gerrymandering - the process of a political party drawing state legislative and congressional maps to maintain or expand their hold on power.

The Wisconsin case didn't do that, but the North Carolina case tries to. It includes a plaintiff from each of the state's 13 congressional districts.

Allison Riggs, an attorney representing the League of Women Voters of North Carolina and other voters who sued, said the state's congressional map provides "the most crystal clear example of why a rule creating limits on partisan gerrymandering is so necessary."

Like Wisconsin, North Carolina is closely divided between Democrats and Republicans, yet Republicans hold a 10-3 edge in congressional seats after the GOP-dominated Legislature created the maps.

They were forced to redraw the congressional map in 2016 after federal courts determined two of the state's districts to be illegal racial gerrymanders. During the latest redrawing, Republicans said they didn't use racial data in forming the maps. Instead, they said maintaining the GOP's 10-3 seat advantage in the state's congressional delegation was one of their guiding standards.

"I think electing Republicans is better than electing Democrats. So I drew this map to help foster what I think is better for the country," one of the mapmakers, Republican state Rep. David Lewis, said during a legislative debate to justify the criteria.

Lewis and other Republican lawmakers have defended their congressional map by saying it splits fewer counties and avoids the severely contorted boundaries that were common under maps drawn since the 1990s by both Democrats and Republicans.

As an example of extreme gerrymandering, the map's critics point to one boundary that splits the historically black and heavily Democratic North Carolina A&T State University campus in Greensboro into two Republican-leaning districts.

The Supreme Court is expected to decide by the end of June whether to hear that case and another one from North Carolina that challenges gerrymandered state legislative boundaries.

On Monday, the U.S. Supreme Court issued a pair of largely procedural rulings in two other redistricting cases.

It agreed that a Maryland congressional district can remain in use while Republicans pursue allegations of unconstitutional partisan gerrymandering by the Democratic governor and legislature.

In the Wisconsin case, the court overturned a lower court ruling from November 2016. That ruling said the map adopted in 2011 by the Republican-led Legislature and Republican governor violated Democratic voters' rights to representation. Democrats had argued that their voters were packed into some districts and spread among others, which had the effect of diluting their voting power.

The Supreme Court rejected the use of a statewide analysis used by 12 Democratic voters who brought the lawsuit. Instead, the court said plaintiffs must prove that their personal voting rights were infringed by the way challenged maps covering 99 Assembly districts were drawn.

Lead attorney Paul Smith said it will take voters in about 20 or 30 districts to show they have been harmed by the current boundaries. To fix those problems will "effectively redraw the entire map," and "at that point, gerrymandering will be effectively remedied."

Justice Elena Kagan provided an alternative route for the plaintiffs. She wrote in a concurrent opinion that a political party might be able to bring a statewide challenge by arguing that a partisan gerrymandered map violates its First Amendment right to freedom of association.

"This case is very much still alive," Smith said while noting both options.

He added: "The bottom line is, there will be plaintiffs with clear standing."

Republicans - who hold a 64-35 majority in the Wisconsin Assembly and 18-15 in the Senate - stood by the maps they drew and said they expected to once again prevail in court.

Smith said speed was of the essence, given that those elected in 2020 - just two years away - will be in place for the next round of redistricting.

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Updated: Teen Killed in Wicomico County Crash Identified

    Updated: Teen Killed in Wicomico County Crash Identified

    Monday, September 24 2018 10:26 PM EDT2018-09-25 02:26:13 GMT
    Tuesday, September 25 2018 3:52 PM EDT2018-09-25 19:52:38 GMT
    (Image: MGN)(Image: MGN)
    (Image: MGN)(Image: MGN)
    A Wicomico County Public Schools official has identified a 17-year-old girl killed in a Monday afternoon car crash.More
    A Wicomico County Public Schools official has identified a 17-year-old girl killed in a Monday afternoon car crash.More
  • 16 Mile Brewery Shuts Down

    16 Mile Brewery Shuts Down

    Monday, September 24 2018 4:45 PM EDT2018-09-24 20:45:11 GMT
    Tuesday, September 25 2018 7:45 AM EDT2018-09-25 11:45:03 GMT
    GEORGETOWN, Del.- After speculation late last week, 16 Mile Brewery has officially closed its doors. On Monday, the local brewery's LED sign on Bedford Street read "Thank you for a great decade." The brewery's doors were locked, the lights off, and a signMore
    GEORGETOWN, Del.- After speculation late last week, 16 Mile Brewery has officially closed its doors. On Monday, the local brewery's LED sign on Bedford Street read "Thank you for a great decade." The brewery's doors were locked, the lights off, and a signMore
  • Health Officials: 50 People May Have Been Exposed to TB at Georgetown Elementary

    Health Officials: 50 People May Have Been Exposed to TB at Georgetown Elementary

    Tuesday, September 25 2018 11:47 AM EDT2018-09-25 15:47:33 GMT
    Tuesday, September 25 2018 3:45 PM EDT2018-09-25 19:45:11 GMT
    Credit: WBOCCredit: WBOC
    Credit: WBOCCredit: WBOC
    The Delaware Division of Public Health and the Indian River School District announced Tuesday that approximately 50 individuals at Georgetown Elementary School may have been exposed to someone with active tuberculosis.More
    The Delaware Division of Public Health and the Indian River School District announced Tuesday that approximately 50 individuals at Georgetown Elementary School may have been exposed to someone with active tuberculosis. More
  • Most Popular VideosMost Popular VideosMore>>

  • 16 Mile Brewery Shuts Down

    16 Mile Brewery Shuts Down

    After speculation late last week, 16 Mile Brewery has officially closed its doors.

    On Monday, the local brewery's LED sign on Bedford Street read "Thank you for a great decade." The brewery's doors were locked, the lights off, and a sign read "CLOSED. We appreciated your business and are sorry to inform you that we have decided to close 16 Mile Brewery and Tavern indefinitely. Thank you for your patronage and support over the last 9 years."

    More

    After speculation late last week, 16 Mile Brewery has officially closed its doors.

    On Monday, the local brewery's LED sign on Bedford Street read "Thank you for a great decade." The brewery's doors were locked, the lights off, and a sign read "CLOSED. We appreciated your business and are sorry to inform you that we have decided to close 16 Mile Brewery and Tavern indefinitely. Thank you for your patronage and support over the last 9 years."

    More
  • Police Investigating Deadly Crash in Wicomico County

    Police Investigating Deadly Crash in Wicomico County

    Maryland State Police are investigating a deadly car crash Friday afternoon. It happened at the intersection of White Lowe Road and Route 50 shortly before 3 p.m. According to MSP, Maria Theresia Ellis, 77 of Ocean City, was driving on White Lowe Road when her car failed to yield to oncoming traffic as she turned onto Route 50. Police said Ellis's car was hit in a T-bone like manner by Garrett Adrian Pusey, 20 of Mardela Springs.

    More

    Maryland State Police are investigating a deadly car crash Friday afternoon. It happened at the intersection of White Lowe Road and Route 50 shortly before 3 p.m. According to MSP, Maria Theresia Ellis, 77 of Ocean City, was driving on White Lowe Road when her car failed to yield to oncoming traffic as she turned onto Route 50. Police said Ellis's car was hit in a T-bone like manner by Garrett Adrian Pusey, 20 of Mardela Springs.

    More
  • Confusing Street Signs Come to Dewey Beach

    Confusing Street Signs Come to Dewey Beach

    New street signs are popping up in Dewey Beach, and some aren't happy about it.

    These new directional signs, Delaware's Department of Transportation says, were implemented to prevent crashes along Route 1.

    But some say it's done the opposite of helping and has created more confusion.

    More

    New street signs are popping up in Dewey Beach, and some aren't happy about it.

    These new directional signs, Delaware's Department of Transportation says, were implemented to prevent crashes along Route 1.

    But some say it's done the opposite of helping and has created more confusion.

    More
Powered by Frankly

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 WBOC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices