Md. to File Court Challenge Over Appointment of Acting AG - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -

Updated: Appointment of Acting Attorney General Challenge in Court

Posted: Updated:
Acting Attorney General Matthew Whitaker was previously a U.S. attorney and frequent Republican candidate for political office in Iowa. (Photo: AP) Acting Attorney General Matthew Whitaker was previously a U.S. attorney and frequent Republican candidate for political office in Iowa. (Photo: AP)

WASHINGTON (AP)- Maryland is challenging the appointment of Matthew Whitaker as the new U.S. acting attorney general, arguing that President Donald Trump sidestepped the Constitution and the Justice Department's own succession plan by elevating Whitaker to the top job.           

The Tuesday filing sets up a court challenge between a state and the federal government over the legitimacy of the country's chief law enforcement officer and foreshadows the likelihood of additional cases that present the same issues.

It comes as Democrats call on Whitaker to recuse himself from overseeing the special counsel's Russia investigation because of critical comments he has made on the probe and amid concerns over his views on the scope of judicial authority.           

In their filing, lawyers in the office of Maryland Attorney General Brian Frosh argue that the job should have gone to Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein instead of to Whitaker.           

They cite a statute governing the line of succession at the Justice Department that says that in the case of a vacancy in the attorney general position, the deputy attorney general may exercise "all the duties of that office." If neither is available for the job, according to that statute, then the associate attorney general is supposed to be elevated.           

Beyond that, the lawyers say, the Constitution requires the duties of the attorney general to be carried out only by someone with Senate confirmation.           

The state argues that Congress always intended for the attorney general to be confirmed by the Senate, given the national security and criminal justice powers of the position, including the authority to control an investigation into the president. Without a set chain of command, according to the filing, a president could pick and remove a series of attorneys general until he got his way.           

"Absent the Attorney General Succession Act, the President could fire the Attorney General (or demand his resignation), then appoint a hand-picked junior Senate-confirmed officer from an entirely different agency, or a carefully selected senior employee who he was confident would terminate or otherwise severely limit the investigation," the filing states.           

A Justice Department spokeswoman had no immediate comment, though the department was expected to release as soon as Tuesday an opinion from its Office of Legal Counsel defending the legitimacy of Whitaker's appointment.           

Whitaker was appointed last year as chief of staff to then-Attorney General Jeff Sessions. He became acting attorney general on Nov. 7 when Sessions was forced out.           

The Maryland filing was made Tuesday in a legal dispute with the Trump administration over the Affordable Care Act. That lawsuit names Sessions as an individual defendant.           

The state asks the judge to substitute Rosenstein as the defendant in place of Sessions, a move that would effectively declare him the proper attorney general.           

The state's lawyers say that in addition to their concerns over the line of succession, Whitaker has "expressed idiosyncratic views that are inconsistent with longstanding Department of Justice policy." They cite his criticism of the landmark Supreme Court opinion Marbury v. Madison, which ensured that courts had authority to strike down laws they considered unconstitutional.

  • Delmarvawide NewsDelmarvawide NewsMore>>

  • Winter Weather Disrupts Air Travel in Mid-Atlantic

    Winter Weather Disrupts Air Travel in Mid-Atlantic

    Wednesday, February 20 2019 10:42 AM EST2019-02-20 15:42:04 GMT
    Wednesday, February 20 2019 11:58 AM EST2019-02-20 16:58:20 GMT
    A winter storm is disrupting air travel in the mid-Atlantic region.More
    A winter storm is disrupting air travel in the mid-Atlantic region.           More
  • Dover Police Searching For Suspect In Convenience Store Robbery

    Dover Police Searching For Suspect In Convenience Store Robbery

    Wednesday, February 20 2019 1:33 PM EST2019-02-20 18:33:32 GMT
    Wednesday, February 20 2019 1:33 PM EST2019-02-20 18:33:32 GMT
    (Photo: MGN Online)(Photo: MGN Online)
    (Photo: MGN Online)(Photo: MGN Online)
    DOVER, Del. - Police are searching for a robber who held up a 7-11 store on South New Street early Wednesday morning. Police say a male suspect entered the store shortly before 6 a.m., pulled out a firearm and demanded the clerk place money in a black booMore
    DOVER, Del. - Police are searching for a robber who held up a 7-11 store on South New Street early Wednesday morning. Police say a male suspect entered the store shortly before 6 a.m., pulled out a firearm and demanded the clerk place money in a black booMore
  • Commission Approves Delaware Memorial Bridge Toll Increase

    Commission Approves Delaware Memorial Bridge Toll Increase

    Wednesday, February 20 2019 11:41 AM EST2019-02-20 16:41:27 GMT
    Wednesday, February 20 2019 11:58 AM EST2019-02-20 16:58:05 GMT
    The Delaware River and Bay Authority Commission approved a revised version of the Delaware Memorial Bridge toll schedule at the bi-state agency’s monthly meeting held Wednesday.More
    The Delaware River and Bay Authority Commission approved a revised version of the Delaware Memorial Bridge toll schedule at the bi-state agency’s monthly meeting held Wednesday.More
Powered by Frankly

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2019 WBOC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices