Judge Dismisses Maryland Suit Seeking to Protect Health Law - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -

Judge Dismisses Maryland Suit Seeking to Protect Health Law

Posted: Updated:
(Photo: MGN Online) (Photo: MGN Online)

BALTIMORE (AP)- A federal judge on Friday dismissed a Maryland lawsuit against President Donald Trump's administration for what it portrayed as recurring efforts to dismantle the national health care law and chase people away from coverage.           

U.S. District Judge Ellen Lipton Hollander wrote in her decision that there's no question about Trump's "profound disdain" for the Affordable Care Act, signed into law in 2010 by his predecessor. But she found the state's allegations speculative, ruling that neither Trump's "zealous attempts to repeal the statute, nor his derisive comments about it, support an inference that he will fail to enforce the law."           

"In effect, the state proclaims the sky is falling. But, falling acorns, even several of them, do not amount to a falling sky," Hollander wrote in her 48-page opinion that entitles Maryland to revive the litigation at some later date.           

Maryland Attorney General Brian Frosh, a Democrat, had sought a declaratory judgment that ACA was constitutional and the Trump administration must stop trying to "sabotage" the Obama-era law twice sustained by the U.S. Supreme Court.           

The opinion in federal court in Maryland comes weeks after a Texas federal judge's December ruling that the Obama health care law is unconstitutional. Although the decision by the Republican-appointed judge in Texas was certainly sweeping, it has had little immediate practical impact because the health care law remains in place while the legal battle continues, possibly to the nation's highest court.           

In the wake of the ruling in Texas, which is under appeal, the federal Health and Human Services Department put out a statement making clear that it "will continue administering and enforcing all aspects of the ACA as it had before the court issued its decision."           

On Friday, Frosh said the effect of the federal court ruling in Maryland was simply that they must wait to pursue their case.           

"We will resume this litigation immediately if the president breaks his promise of continued enforcement or when the stay of the Texas court's decision is lifted," Frosh said in a statement.           

In its lawsuit from last year, Maryland also sought to challenge Matthew Whitaker's appointment as the country's acting attorney general. William Barr has since been chosen as Trump's nominee for attorney general.           

 

  • Delmarvawide NewsDelmarvawide NewsMore>>

  • Beach Replenishment Begins in Rehoboth Beach

    Beach Replenishment Begins in Rehoboth Beach

    Monday, October 21 2019 4:30 PM EDT2019-10-21 20:30:49 GMT
    Monday, October 21 2019 4:47 PM EDT2019-10-21 20:47:05 GMT
    Great Lakes Dredge and Dock Company moved its equipment onto Deauville Beach Monday morning. More than 400,000 cubic yards of sand will be pumped from offshore onto Rehoboth and Dewey Beach.More
    Great Lakes Dredge and Dock Company moved its equipment onto Deauville Beach Monday morning. More than 400,000 cubic yards of sand will be pumped from offshore onto Rehoboth and Dewey Beach.More
  • Barber Says Dover Zoning Laws Too Restrictive

    Barber Says Dover Zoning Laws Too Restrictive

    Monday, October 21 2019 8:09 PM EDT2019-10-22 00:09:50 GMT
    Monday, October 21 2019 8:11 PM EDT2019-10-22 00:11:39 GMT
    Joseph Chilcote.Joseph Chilcote.
    Joseph Chilcote.Joseph Chilcote.
    DOVER, Del. --- Joseph Chilcote has always wanted to open up a barber shop in Downtown Dover. The Wyoming, Del. resident has been a licensed barber for years and sees clients at his home but he recently received an offer from one of his clients to open upMore
    DOVER, Del. --- Joseph Chilcote has always wanted to open up a barber shop in Downtown Dover. The Wyoming, Del. resident has been a licensed barber for years and sees clients at his home but he recently received an offer from one of his clients to open upMore
  • Sussex County Considers Lodging Tax for Venues Outside City Limits

    Sussex County Considers Lodging Tax for Venues Outside City Limits

    Monday, October 21 2019 7:00 PM EDT2019-10-21 23:00:33 GMT
    Monday, October 21 2019 7:00 PM EDT2019-10-21 23:00:33 GMT
    The Sussex County council will consider a lodging tax for hotels, motels and tourists homes in unincorporated areas of the county.More
    The Sussex County council will consider a lodging tax for hotels, motels and tourists homes in unincorporated areas of the county. More
  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Barber Says Dover Zoning Laws Too Restrictive

    Barber Says Dover Zoning Laws Too Restrictive

    Monday, October 21 2019 8:09 PM EDT2019-10-22 00:09:50 GMT
    Monday, October 21 2019 8:11 PM EDT2019-10-22 00:11:39 GMT
    Joseph Chilcote.Joseph Chilcote.
    Joseph Chilcote.Joseph Chilcote.
    DOVER, Del. --- Joseph Chilcote has always wanted to open up a barber shop in Downtown Dover. The Wyoming, Del. resident has been a licensed barber for years and sees clients at his home but he recently received an offer from one of his clients to open upMore
    DOVER, Del. --- Joseph Chilcote has always wanted to open up a barber shop in Downtown Dover. The Wyoming, Del. resident has been a licensed barber for years and sees clients at his home but he recently received an offer from one of his clients to open upMore
  • South State Street in Dover Closed Following Sunday Night Structural Damage

    South State Street in Dover Closed Following Sunday Night Structural Damage

    Monday, October 21 2019 12:48 PM EDT2019-10-21 16:48:43 GMT
    Monday, October 21 2019 1:07 PM EDT2019-10-21 17:07:53 GMT
    The building at 304 S. State Street has been condemned by the Dover Fire Marshal following damage discovered Sunday night.The building at 304 S. State Street has been condemned by the Dover Fire Marshal following damage discovered Sunday night.
    The building at 304 S. State Street has been condemned by the Dover Fire Marshal following damage discovered Sunday night.The building at 304 S. State Street has been condemned by the Dover Fire Marshal following damage discovered Sunday night.
    South State Street in Dover remains closed off to traffic after structural damage was discovered at a building in Downtown Dover on Sunday night, according to city officials.More
    South State Street in Dover remains closed off to traffic after structural damage was discovered at a building in Downtown Dover on Sunday night, according to city officials.More
  • Three Men Arrested on Drug Charges During Salisbury Traffic Stop

    Three Men Arrested on Drug Charges During Salisbury Traffic Stop

    Monday, October 21 2019 12:25 AM EDT2019-10-21 04:25:53 GMT
    Monday, October 21 2019 7:40 AM EDT2019-10-21 11:40:05 GMT
    Photo: Maryland State PolicePhoto: Maryland State Police
    Photo: Maryland State PolicePhoto: Maryland State Police
    Maryland State Police arrested three man on drug charges early Sunday morning during a traffic stop.More
    Maryland State Police arrested three man on drug charges early Sunday morning during a traffic stop.More
  • Most Popular VideosMost Popular VideosMore>>

  • South State Street in Dover Closed Following Sunday Night Structural Damage

    South State Street in Dover Closed Following Sunday Night Structural Damage

    The building at 304 S. State Street has been condemned by the Dover Fire Marshal following damage diThe building at 304 S. State Street has been condemned by the Dover Fire Marshal following damage di
    The building at 304 S. State Street has been condemned by the Dover Fire Marshal following damage discovered Sunday night.The building at 304 S. State Street has been condemned by the Dover Fire Marshal following damage discovered Sunday night.

    South State Street in Dover remains closed off to traffic after structural damage was discovered at a building in Downtown Dover on Sunday night, according to city officials.

    More

    South State Street in Dover remains closed off to traffic after structural damage was discovered at a building in Downtown Dover on Sunday night, according to city officials.

    More
  • Beach Replenishment Begins in Rehoboth Beach

    Beach Replenishment Begins in Rehoboth Beach

    Great Lakes Dredge and Dock Company moved its equipment onto Deauville Beach Monday morning. More than 400,000 cubic yards of sand will be pumped from offshore onto Rehoboth and Dewey Beach. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers funded 65 percent of the $7.21 million project.  Delaware Department of Natural Resources (DNREC) funded 35 percent.

    More

    Great Lakes Dredge and Dock Company moved its equipment onto Deauville Beach Monday morning. More than 400,000 cubic yards of sand will be pumped from offshore onto Rehoboth and Dewey Beach. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers funded 65 percent of the $7.21 million project.  Delaware Department of Natural Resources (DNREC) funded 35 percent.

    More
  • Barber Says Dover Zoning Laws Too Restrictive

    Barber Says Dover Zoning Laws Too Restrictive

    Joseph Chilcote.Joseph Chilcote.
    Joseph Chilcote.Joseph Chilcote.

    Joseph Chilcote has always wanted to open up a barber shop in Downtown Dover.

    The Wyoming, Del. resident has been a licensed barber for years and sees clients at his home but he recently received an offer from one of his clients to open up a shop on South State Street.

    More

    Joseph Chilcote has always wanted to open up a barber shop in Downtown Dover.

    The Wyoming, Del. resident has been a licensed barber for years and sees clients at his home but he recently received an offer from one of his clients to open up a shop on South State Street.

    More
Powered by Frankly

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2019 WBOC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices