Watermen, Environmentalists Debate over Dredging Prehistoric Oys - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -

Watermen, Environmentalists Debate over Dredging Prehistoric Oyster Bar

Posted: Updated:
Credit: Maryland DNR Credit: Maryland DNR

ANNAPOLIS, Md. - It's another showdown between watermen and environmentalists - this time in Annapolis. On Tuesday, a committee of Maryland lawmakers heard testimony from both groups over dredging a prehistoric oyster bar known as Man O' War Shoal. Last year, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers gave the state permission to dredge the area on the Western Shore near the mouth of the Patapsco River. But now, an emergency bill, known as Senate Bill 145, would ensure Man O' War Shoal and its estimated 100 million bushels of oyster shells stays untouched and closed off.

Watermen like Jeff Harrison say dredging would bring as much as 5 million bushels of natural shell for baby oysters to grow on to other parts of the Chesapeake Bay.

"Natural is the way we want to go, yes," Harrison said. "If this bills passes, I mean, we're totally against it because we really need those shells. Shells are the most important substrate to the Bay right now."

But environmentalists argue differently, Alan Girard of the Chesapeake Bay Foundation says dredging the area could devastate nearby fish habitat and do little to bring back oysters.

"We need to make sure these natural areas stay protected," Girard said. "It's a small amount of shell for not very great benefits when you look at the alternatives that are out there."

Girard says one alternative includes what's been done in places like Harris Creek: man-made, concrete bottom proven to help oysters grow.

But Harrison says he remains skeptical of that alternative, standing by the use of natural shell to replenish and save the Chesapeake Bay.

According to the Maryland Department of Natural Resources, dredging Man O' War Shoal would cost about $27 million. Watermen, like Harrison, say it's money that would bring priceless benefits to the Bay. But environmentalists say all the money should be used in other ways that include restoring and protecting existing oyster reefs in Maryland.

  • Delmarvawide NewsDelmarvawide NewsMore>>

  • School Choice Process Starts in Delaware

    School Choice Process Starts in Delaware

    Thursday, November 21 2019 4:48 PM EST2019-11-21 21:48:00 GMT
    Thursday, November 21 2019 4:48 PM EST2019-11-21 21:48:00 GMT
    Parents in the first state have already taken advantage of the school choice program to start applying to their children's school for next fall.More
    Parents in the first state have already taken advantage of the school choice program to start applying to their children's school for next fall.More
  • Affidavit Alleges Milton-Area Woman Abused Own Children Over Months

    Affidavit Alleges Milton-Area Woman Abused Own Children Over Months

    Thursday, November 21 2019 7:41 PM EST2019-11-22 00:41:29 GMT
    Thursday, November 21 2019 10:05 PM EST2019-11-22 03:05:39 GMT
    Christina Morris. (Delaware State Police)Christina Morris. (Delaware State Police)
    Christina Morris. (Delaware State Police)Christina Morris. (Delaware State Police)
    GEORGETOWN, Del. --- Two children of a Milton-area woman arrested last week on multiple charges of child abuse told state troopers their mother had subjected either of them to months of abuse involving a baseball bat, a high heel shoe, and even boiling waMore
    GEORGETOWN, Del. --- Two children of a Milton-area woman arrested last week on multiple charges of child abuse told state troopers their mother had subjected either of them to months of abuse involving a baseball bat, a high heel shoe, and even boiling waMore
  • Delaware State University Cuts Ribbon On A New Dorm With A Historic Name

    Delaware State University Cuts Ribbon On A New Dorm With A Historic Name

    Thursday, November 21 2019 7:06 PM EST2019-11-22 00:06:25 GMT
    Thursday, November 21 2019 7:06 PM EST2019-11-22 00:06:25 GMT
    Delaware State University is rapidly growing and a new state of the art dorm is now open to help with that. School officials and sponsors cut the ribbon on Thursday morning for a new home for over 600 students.More
    Delaware State University is rapidly growing and a new state of the art dorm is now open to help with that. School officials and sponsors cut the ribbon on Thursday morning for a new home for over 600 students. More
  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Ocean City's Pet Policy Challenged by Hotel Owners

    Hotel Owners Challenge Ocean City's Pet Policy

    Wednesday, November 20 2019 11:42 PM EST2019-11-21 04:42:04 GMT
    Thursday, November 21 2019 7:15 AM EST2019-11-21 12:15:52 GMT
    Ocean City hotel owners are challenging the resort town's pet policy.More
    Ocean City hotel owners are challenging the resort town's pet policy.More
  • Missouri Jail Escapee Captured in Makeshift Hut in Delaware

    Missouri Jail Escapee Captured in Makeshift Hut in Delaware

    Thursday, November 21 2019 11:13 AM EST2019-11-21 16:13:28 GMT
    Thursday, November 21 2019 11:13 AM EST2019-11-21 16:13:28 GMT
    U.S. Marshals say Drake Kately was found hiding in this makeshift hut he made in New Castle County, Del. (Photo: US. Marshals Service)U.S. Marshals say Drake Kately was found hiding in this makeshift hut he made in New Castle County, Del. (Photo: US. Marshals Service)
    U.S. Marshals say Drake Kately was found hiding in this makeshift hut he made in New Castle County, Del. (Photo: US. Marshals Service)U.S. Marshals say Drake Kately was found hiding in this makeshift hut he made in New Castle County, Del. (Photo: US. Marshals Service)
    PRINCETON, Mo. (AP/WBOC)- Authorities say an inmate who escaped twice from a Missouri jail was captured more than 1,000 miles away in Delaware where he was living in a makeshift hut in a wooded area. The U.S. Marshals Service says in a news release that 2More
    PRINCETON, Mo. (AP/WBOC)- Authorities say an inmate who escaped twice from a Missouri jail was captured more than 1,000 miles away in Delaware where he was living in a makeshift hut in a wooded area. The U.S. Marshals Service says in a news release that 2More
  • GM Recalls 640K Pickups; Seat Belts Can Cause Carpet Fires

    GM Recalls 640K Pickups; Seat Belts Can Cause Carpet Fires

    Thursday, November 21 2019 9:33 AM EST2019-11-21 14:33:52 GMT
    Thursday, November 21 2019 9:38 AM EST2019-11-21 14:38:22 GMT
    (Photo: MGN Online)(Photo: MGN Online)
    (Photo: MGN Online)(Photo: MGN Online)
    General Motors is recalling over 640,000 pickup trucks worldwide because hot gas from a high-tech seat belt can set the carpeting on fire.More
    General Motors is recalling over 640,000 pickup trucks worldwide because hot gas from a high-tech seat belt can set the carpeting on fire.           More
Powered by Frankly

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2019 WBOC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices