Attorney: Alleged Md. Newspaper Gunman 'Evil as All Get-out' - WBOC-TV 16, Delmarvas News Leader, FOX 21 -

Attorney: Alleged Md. Newspaper Gunman 'Evil as All Get-out'

Posted: Updated:

By BRIAN WITTE, Associated Press           

ANNAPOLIS, Md. (AP)- A lawyer said Thursday that "evil as all get-out" would be a better way of describing the man accused of fatally shooting five people at a Maryland newspaper, rather than calling him "crazy."           

Brennan McCarthy, who represented a woman harassed by Jarrod Ramos years ago, testified at a pretrial hearing as prosecutors and defense attorneys continued to battle about whether prosecutors properly shared information about the case with the defense. Ramos faces scheduled trial in November on five counts of first-degree murder.           

Defense attorneys for Ramos subpoenaed McCarthy, because they believe he may have documents to support the defendant's plea of not criminally responsible - Maryland's version of an insanity defense. Defense attorneys say McCarthy told police the day of the June 2018 shooting at the Capital Gazette that he believed Ramos was "crazy."           

But McCarthy told Judge Laura Ripken on Thursday that he is not a mental health expert and implied he didn't mean to use the word literally with police in describing Ramos.           

McCarthy also rebutted arguments from public defender William Davis that he kept regular tabs on Ramos and had longtime knowledge of Ramos' mental state, because McCarthy was afraid of statements Ramos made on Twitter - both for himself and his sister, Kathleen Kirchner.           

"You don't follow the devil," McCarthy said. "You hide from him."           

Ramos is accused of blasting into the Capital Gazette's newsroom with a shotgun and killing Gerald Fischman, Rob Hiaasen, John McNamara, Wendi Winters and Rebecca Smith, as other employees hid under desks. Police say Ramos was arrested hiding under a desk in the newsroom.           

Ramos, 39, had a well-documented history of harassing the Capital Gazette's staff. He filed a defamation suit against the newspaper in 2012 that was thrown out as groundless, and he often railed against the media outlet in profanity-laced tweets.           

His anger at the newspaper began with an online harassment and stalking case stemming from contact with a high school classmate in late 2009 or early 2010. The woman eventually went to police, and Ramos pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor harassment charge. The newspaper's story about the case touched off a tirade from Ramos.           

Defense attorneys have been arguing for months over issues relating to discovery, a legal process involving evidence exchanges between the defense and the prosecution. Prosecutors say they have gone above and beyond the requirements for sharing information with the defense.           

Ripken ruled for McCarthy to submit documents that could be discoverable relating to his former client for her to review and decide whether they should be turned over to the defense. McCarthy, however, said he doesn't believe he has any, because the case is so old.           

Defense attorneys also have been seeking more information from Kirchner. Her husband, Richard Kirchner, who has conducted threat assessments in various jobs with the federal government, had conducted such an assessment in 2014, based on tweets sent by Ramos, after his wife asked him to do so. He said the assessment was done orally, and there is no written document.           

He told reporters at the courthouse Thursday that he believed McCarthy and his wife were in danger, and he told his wife to not be involved in the case.           

"You need to get off this man's radar," he said he recalled telling her.           

Richard Kirchner described Ramos as "a classic wound collector," amassing grievances against people. He described Ramos as being similar to other mass shooters.           

"I would absolutely put him in those levels," he told reporters during a break in the court hearing.           

Kathleen Kirchner ended up expressing her concerns to Anne Arundel County State's Attorney Anne Colt Leitess at the time, and asked her to see if a crime had been committed. Leitess wrote in an email that she would have investigators look into it. But defense attorneys say they never received any documents about such an investigation.           

Defense attorneys are asking Ripken to sanction prosecutors for failing to turn over documents that should be shared with them, even suggesting that Leitess should be recused from the case. But Leitess vehemently denied the accusation, as the hearing became more heated late Thursday afternoon. Leitess said prosecutors have gone "above and beyond" in releasing information in their possession related to the upcoming trial.           

Ripken said she would rule on the matter during another hearing scheduled for Oct. 2.

  • Delmarvawide NewsDelmarvawide NewsMore>>

  • Wicomico County Safe Station Provides Immediate Care for People Battling Addiction

    Wicomico County Safe Station Provides Immediate Care for People Battling Addiction

    Wednesday, September 18 2019 8:42 AM EDT2019-09-18 12:42:47 GMT
    Wednesday, September 18 2019 9:01 AM EDT2019-09-18 13:01:59 GMT
    (Photo: WBOC)(Photo: WBOC)
    (Photo: WBOC)(Photo: WBOC)
    As communities across the country continue to grapple with the opioid epidemic, a new space in Wicomico County is hoping to make a difference. It's called a "safe station," and it is designed to help those battling addiction receive immediate care.More
    As communities across the country continue to grapple with the opioid epidemic, a new space in Wicomico County is hoping to make a difference. It's called a "safe station," and it is designed to help those battling addiction receive immediate care.More
  • Two Dead in Parsonsburg Motorcycle Accident

    Two Dead in Parsonsburg Motorcycle Accident

    Wednesday, September 18 2019 4:05 AM EDT2019-09-18 08:05:06 GMT
    Wednesday, September 18 2019 7:31 AM EDT2019-09-18 11:31:53 GMT
    Maryland State Police are investigating the death of two people after they were thrown from a motorcycle late Tuesday night.More
    Maryland State Police are investigating the death of two people after they were thrown from a motorcycle late Tuesday night.More
  • Va. Investigating Over-The-Counter Male Enhancement Pill

    Va. Investigating Over-The-Counter Male Enhancement Pill

    Wednesday, September 18 2019 7:23 AM EDT2019-09-18 11:23:26 GMT
    Wednesday, September 18 2019 7:30 AM EDT2019-09-18 11:30:38 GMT
    (Photo: MGN)(Photo: MGN)
    (Photo: MGN)(Photo: MGN)
    Virginia state health officials are investigating reports that an over-the-counter male enhancement pill sold at convenience stores and gas stations is sending men to the hospital with very low blood sugar levels.More
    Virginia state health officials are investigating reports that an over-the-counter male enhancement pill sold at convenience stores and gas stations is sending men to the hospital with very low blood sugar levels.More
  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Two Dead in Parsonsburg Motorcycle Accident

    Two Dead in Parsonsburg Motorcycle Accident

    Wednesday, September 18 2019 4:05 AM EDT2019-09-18 08:05:06 GMT
    Wednesday, September 18 2019 7:31 AM EDT2019-09-18 11:31:53 GMT
    Maryland State Police are investigating the death of two people after they were thrown from a motorcycle late Tuesday night.More
    Maryland State Police are investigating the death of two people after they were thrown from a motorcycle late Tuesday night.More
  • Seaford 911 Center Loses Employees

    Seaford 911 Center Loses Employees

    Tuesday, September 17 2019 8:02 PM EDT2019-09-18 00:02:30 GMT
    Wednesday, September 18 2019 7:27 AM EDT2019-09-18 11:27:32 GMT
    Since the City of Seaford announced plans to shut down the 911 Center and redirect calls to the Emergency Operations Center in Georgetown, two dispatchers have quit, and at least four others are in close talks with other agencies.More
    Since the City of Seaford announced plans to shut down the 911 Center and redirect calls to the Emergency Operations Center in Georgetown, two dispatchers have quit, and at least four others are in close talks with other agencies.More
  • Climate Change Threatens Biden Beach House

    Climate Change Threatens Biden Beach House

    Tuesday, September 17 2019 5:47 PM EDT2019-09-17 21:47:06 GMT
    Wednesday, September 18 2019 7:20 AM EDT2019-09-18 11:20:20 GMT
    One flooding model shows Joe Biden's North Shores home and others in the community completely underwater in 80 years.More
    One flooding model shows former Vice President Joe Biden's North Shores home and others in the community completely underwater in 80 years.More
Powered by Frankly

All content © Copyright 2000 - 2019 WBOC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service, and Ad Choices