CHINCOTEAGUE ISLAND, Va. - Directors at the Museum of Chincoteague Island are asking the public to help solve a mystery.
While preparing the historic Beebe Ranch for its public grand opening this summer, museum staff discovered a photograph tucked away in the attic. The identity of the man in the framed portrait remains unknown.
“Part of the process has been going through the attic, which is an absolute treasure trove of artifacts and letters,” said Cindy Faith, the museum’s assistant director.
Faith said she originally thought the portrait had no identifying information. But after peeling back the backing, she discovered a name—believed to be a member of the Hill family. “Initially, I didn't think there was a name on the back, but I pried in and I did see a name behind the backing, which is a Hill family member,” said Faith.
Museum officials believe the man may be Drummond Hill, likely pictured around 1880. But to confirm that, they’re turning to the island community for help.
“There’s a lot of connection. Years ago, this was a very small town. I mean, we’re still a small town—2,800 people—years ago was even smaller. A lot of the family stories are intertwined. So, even though this is a Beebe Ranch story, it’s also a Hill family story,” Faith said.
The Hill family was known for its role in the seafood trade, and some descendants still live on the island today.
“It’s always exciting to find unexpected treasures. And, through this portrait, we may be able to enhance the story of the ranch and what went on there and give a little more history for our visitors to learn about,” said Kathy Martin, the museum’s executive director.
Museum leaders hope someone will recognize the man in the photo and help piece together another chapter of the island’s history.
The grand opening of the Beebe Ranch is scheduled for June 28.